The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Microsoft's Breakup Overturned, Antitrust Violation Upheld

Microsoft's Breakup Overturned, Antitrust Violation Upheld

by , 1:10 PM EDT, June 28th, 2001

Microsoft has won a major, but mixed victory in its appeal of an order to break up the company based on the companies violation of the Sherman Antitrust Act. That ruling was handed down by Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson last year, and the appeals process began this year. Microsoft has argued that not only was the company innocent, but that Judge Jackson was clearly biased based on statements made to the press while the trial was being held. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia has ruled that Judge Jackson did indeed give the appearance of bias, but upheld that Microsoft had violated the Sherman Antitrust Act. They have sent the case back down to a lower court for a new remedy. According to an AP report:

A federal appeals court unanimously reversed the breakup of Microsoft on Thursday, agreeing with the software maker that the trial judge engaged in "serious judicial misconduct" by making derogatory comments about the company. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia upheld the conclusion that Microsoft violated antitrust laws but ordered that a new judge decide what penalty the company should face.

By a 7-0 vote, the appeals court concluded U.S. District Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson made inappropriate comments to the news media and outside court that gave the appearance he was biased against Microsoft. While reversing the breakup, the court refused to overturn the conclusion that Microsoft acted as an illegal monopoly to gain an unfair advantage over competitors, particularly those with rival Web browser software.

The appeals judges said they agreed "with the District Court that the company behaved anti-competitively ... and that these actions contributed to the maintenance of its monopoly power."

The court also handed Microsoft a smaller victory by reversing one finding by Jackson that its packaging of its Web browser and operating system violated antitrust law. The judges said the government, in the new phase of the trial, would have to show that Microsoft "unreasonably restrained competition" with that action.

The appellate decision that Microsoft may be able to package the products together was reached, the judges said, because they feared that such a prohibition on packaging software may impede operating system innovation." The appeals court said it only reversed Jackson's penalty decision because, "The most serious judicial misconduct occurred near or during the remedial stage. It is therefore commensurate that our remedy focus on that stage of the case."

Microsoft has so far been mum on the ruling. Microsoft's stock was trading at 72, up 86 cents as of this writing.

The Mac Observer Spin:

We have an extended opinion coming shortly. For now, we will say that this is not really that big a victory for Microsoft and that they still face a serious challenge to their misuse of monopoly power.

Recent Headlines - Updated October 22nd

Tue,8:51 PM
GTAT Announces ‘Amicable Parting’ of Ways with Apple
6:50 PM
How I Came to Own and Sell a TAM Probably Owned by Jony Ive
5:01 PM
Adobe KnowHow: Learn Photography From The Best for $29.99
4:49 PM
How To Get Ready For iOS 8.1 [Update]
2:59 PM
Chuck La Tournous and Chris Breen to Speak at NJMUG’s 30th Anniversary Tuesday
2:24 PM
Don’t Upgrade to Yosemite or iOS 8.1 Before You Read This Column
2:06 PM
TMO Daily Observations: 2014-10-21
12:29 PM
How Apple Pay Mitigates Breach Fatigue
10:50 AM
How to Enable Apple’s SMS Relay on your Mac or iPad
9:43 AM
Apple Earnings Smackdown Ranks Analyst Predictions
Mon,9:52 PM
Apple Q4 Earnings Sliced And Diced
8:21 PM
Apple Q4 MacBook Sales Hit Record Breaking Numbers, Jump 25 Percent
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!