The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
BusinessWeek Looks Askance At Gore Appointment

BusinessWeek Looks Askance At Gore Appointment

by , 11:00 AM EST, March 27th, 2003

Alex Salkever, current author of Charles Haddad's "Byte of the Apple" column (Mr. Haddad is on leave), doesn't think too highly of Apple's newest Board member. Mr. Salkever piece, titled "Why Apple Shouldn't Vote for Gore," cites a number of reasons for why he thinks Al Gore makes a poor choice for Apple's board of directors, most of which center around the notion that Al Gore doesn't offer the appearance of an independent director. According to Mr. Salkever, Apple needs that independence. From the article:

With its stock price down over the past two years, the last thing Apple shareholders want or need is a celebrity director with zero business experience, aside from the business of fund-raising and politicking. Gore might make a wonderful contribution to Apple in some other capacity. But Jobs & Co. should think long and hard about the message it sends to shareholders with this appointment.


Over the past two years, Apple has declined to make clear the process by which Jobs is compensated. The board has put in place no clear triggers for his performance bonuses, something that's considered necessary in board-CEO relationships. Which may explain, in part, why Jobs got a $90 million jet in 2002, while his shareholders watched Apple stock sink from $23.46 to $14.55, a 38% decline.

According to Paul Hodgson, a researcher at The Corporate Library, this raises the question of whether Jobs is exerting undue influence over compensation policies. That violates a sacred principle in corporate governance: Executive-pay decisions should be made by directors shielded from meddling by top execs. Says Hodgson: "It sounds like an idea they cooked up among themselves, with Jobs in there telling them what he wanted."

Earlier today, we mentioned a piece by David Zeiler with comments from Needham analyst Charles Wolf, who has a much higher opinion of Apple's board. As for Mr. Salkever's thoughts, there is much more information in the full article at BusinessWeek's Web site.

The Mac Observer Spin:

Of all the reasons that have been listed by people displeased with the Gore appointment, Mr. Salkever's complaint that he isn't independent enough is the first well-reasoned argument, and that makes it refreshing.

That said, we question his reasoning. Apple may well need more independent directors, but that doesn't mean that Al Gore's political experience can't help Apple in today's tech-meddling political environment. That, for those keeping score at home, is why we think Mr. Gore can, in fact, help Apple. Dismissing Al Gore's potential to help Apple for the supposed sins of the current board seems capricious, at best.

We understand that your mileage is very likely to vary on this issue, but we ask that you to keep the conversation on-topic and polite. Out-of-control posts will be deleted.

Recent TMO Headlines - Updated June 26th

Fri, 5:06 PM
’Obi-Wan Kenobi’ Star Moses Ingram to Join Cast of Apple TV+ Series ‘Lady in the Lake’
Fri, 4:31 PM
Chris Evans Stuns the Internet By Upgrading His iPhone 6
Fri, 4:12 PM
Leaks Suggest Next AirPods Pro to Upgraded H1 Chip, Find My, Heart Rate Detection, USB-C and More
Fri, 3:06 PM
Rumors Suggest Apple to Announce 'Game-Changer' AR/MR Headset January 2023
Fri, 3:05 PM
Apple’s Back to School Promo Could Score You a $150 Gift Card
Fri, 2:21 PM
Apple-1 'Byte Shop' Model Goes for $375,000 at Thursday Auction
Fri, 1:22 PM
Code in iOS 16 Betas Hint at New Siri Remote for Apple TV
Fri, 8:32 AM
Apple’s Long Game in Mobile and Portable Computing; Choice and Versatility
Fri, 7:32 AM
Apple Music Student Plan Gets a Price Increase in US, UK and Canada
Fri, 7:03 AM
Google Chrome on iOS Gets Five New Features
Thu, 5:40 PM
Using Measurement Conversions in iOS 16
Thu, 4:37 PM
Apple TV+ Series 'Trying' Reveals Season 3 Trailer Before July Premiere
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Daily Observations
  • TMO on Twitter!