The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Real to Sell iPod-Ready Songs in Running Apple Tiff

TMO Reports - Real to Sell iPod-Ready Songs in Running Apple Tiff

by , 7:10 AM EDT, July 26th, 2004

The fued between RealNetworks and Apple Computer over the Mac makers refusal to license its digital rights management (DRM) technology is expected to heat up another notch Monday as Real has announced new software that allows songs purchased through its online music store to be played on any portable media player, including Apple's iPod.

Until now, other companies have been unable to offer people the ability to buy music from their service and play it on the popular iPod, which is the best selling portable music device in the world. Apple has blocked that ability by refusing to license the use of its FairPlay DRM to companies seeking iPod compatibility.

Songs bought through the iTunes Music Store are encrypted using FairPlay, which works only with the iPod. In addition, the iPod doesn't support DRM technologies used by other services, like Windows Media Audio and RealNetworks' Helix technology.

But the RealNetworks technology has apparently broken through Apple's technology using reverse engineering to gain the ability to play its music files on an iPod. RealNetworks did not seek permission from Apple before releasing the software.

In April, RealNetworks chief executive Rob Glaser sent an e-mail to Apple CEO Steve Jobs, asking him to license Apple's Fairplay. Jobs never replied telling analyst at the time that Apple's dominance in the market gave it little reason to partner with RealNetworks or anyone else.

The controversial move could trigger legal action by Apple after it tears apart the RealNetworks code of the new technology called Harmony to figure out if it legally violates any copyright. Mr. Glaser said his company had not violated any of Apple's intellectual property rights. "We have excellent lawyers and they assure me that we are 100% within all of the legal precedents and the letter and spirit of all laws," Mr. Glaser told the The Wall Street Journal.

As for Mac users, the Real announcement could offer additional choice down the road of where to buy music which has been unavailable until now. People familiar with the RealNetworks technology tell The Mac Observer RealNetworks could decide to release a new version of RealPlayer for Mac in the future that would allow Mac users to buy songs at 99 cents each from Real's Rhapsody music service and play them on their Mac or on their iPod. Initially, Real will only offer an iPod compatible vesion of RealPlayer for Windows users. RealNetworks has made no announcement that it plans at this time to release a new Mac version of RealPlayer to offer such compatibility.

"A long time from now, people will look back at our announcement and say it was a great benefit for Apple," Mr. Glaser told The New York Times.

In an interview with the The Wall Street Journal, Mr. Glaser said he feels the best way for everyone to reap the benefits of digital music distribution is for all companies to have one, uniform standard, instead of different standards from RealNetworks, Microsoft, Sony and Apple, to name a few.

"There's a format war. It's clear to us you're not going to get past the early-adopter phase unless you solve that problem," Mr. Glaser told WSJ.

An Apple spokesperson had no comment on the Real announcement.

Recent Headlines - Updated November 1st

Fri,6:58 PM
Pee-Wee Herman Stars in Avengers Trailer
6:34 PM
Trent Reznor on Working for Apple: ‘It’s Everything I Asked For’
5:50 PM
Last Chance for The Complete iOS 8 Course With Swift for $89
4:42 PM
MacTech Conference 2014: Talk to Kelly and Dave!
4:30 PM
Apple Wins the Old-fashioned Way: Outsmart the Competition
3:00 PM
Judge Rules Cops can Force You to Touch ID Unlock your iPhone
2:02 PM
iOS 8: Adding Fitness App Data to the Health App
1:16 PM
TMO Daily Observations: 2014-10-31
11:25 AM
How To Clean Up and Rebuild Apple Mail Data [Yosemite Update]
9:39 AM
Judge to Unseal GT Advanced Bankruptcy Filing Documents
8:45 AM
Yosemite: Maximizing Windows & the Green “Stoplight” Button
Thu,7:17 PM
Meijer, the CurrenctC/MCX Member Who Refuses to Block Apple Pay
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!