The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Mercury News Calls Apple's Anti-Rumor Lawsuits "Misguided"

Mercury News Calls Apple's Anti-Rumor Lawsuits "Misguided"

by , 1:20 PM EST, March 10th, 2005

Apple's lawsuits against Think Secret, PowerPage, and AppleInsider are "misguided," according to an editorial published Thursday by Apple's home town newspaper, the San Jose Mercury News.

The editorial said the sites perform the same function as traditional media outlets like print trade magazines and newspapers, and deserve the same protections as traditional journalists. Such protections, said the editorial, are "essential to a free press."

At issue is one lawsuit accusing Think Secret of publishing Apple's Trade Secrets that seeks to force the site to reveal its sources, as well as subpoenas issued to PowerPage, AppleInsider, and Think Secret in a separate case against John Does (unknown persons) also seeking their sources.

Apple's legal argument has heretofore been that these sites are not run by "journalists," and are therefore not eligible for protections granted to journalists.

"It's a puzzling and misguided argument," wrote the unsigned author of the piece. "The Web sites have been writing about Apple for some time. The people behind them collect information that is of interest to the public and publish it for the consumption, primarily, of a throng of avid Macintosh fans. In other words, they perform a function that is little different from that of scores of trade publications, or even the business sections of major newspapers."

The piece concluded with, "If the judge rules against the Web sites, this is a case that ought to be appealed to a higher court."

Recent Headlines - Updated July 8th

Tue,9:43 PM
Falling Sales Suggest Apple Watch Isn’t Resonating with Consumers
7:05 PM
Standalone Showtime Apps Hit Apple TV and App Store
4:30 PM
A Working Star Trek Communicator (Bluetooth) Handset
4:09 PM
SplashID Pro Lifetime Plan - $24.99
3:15 PM
2 Apple Watch Charging Stands for Travel Compared
1:09 PM
TMO Daily Observations 2015-07-07: Apple’s Product Packaging Rules, iOS 8.4 Home Sharing
11:38 AM
LEGO Ideas Brings Ada Lovelace, Analytic Engine to Life
10:07 AM
Apple’s Eddy Cue: Music Home Sharing Could Return in iOS 9
8:50 AM
Apple Music: Three Quick Tips!
Mon,9:29 PM
Amazon Cloud Drive Comes to iOS App Store
7:40 PM
PHATASS, the Prince Harvey Rap Album Recorded at an Apple Store
5:55 PM
An Electric Car Won this Year’s Pikes Peak Hill Climb
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!