The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Pro and Con: Should Apple Buy Palm?

Pro and Con: Should Apple Buy Palm?

by , 4:15 PM EST, December 19th, 2005

Acquisition scenarios are all the rage these days, with many Internet pundits speculating on what company Apple should buy, or vice-versa. Brett Arends, writing for the Boston Herald on Monday, believes Apple CEO Steve Jobs should "take advantage of his soaring share price to open up whole new fields of growth" and buy Palm. However, O'Reilly Network columnist Fraser Spiers disagrees with him.

Mr. Arends' reasoning is that "iPods are not quite as invincible as they look," arguing that Apple's refusal in the 1980s to license the Macintosh operating system is similar to the fact that iTunes Music Store purchases will play only on an iPod.

With Palm's current net value of US$1.1 billion, Mr. Arends reasons that Apple could spend 2% of its shares to make the purchase "but immediately add 10% to sales and gross profits." In addition, while the iPod is "the must-have product for Christmas 2005," the deal would give Apple the must-have gift for later holiday buying seasons.

Not So Fast

While Mr. Spiers agrees that Apple should produce a PDA, he doesn't see the point in the company acquiring Palm. He sees "very little difference" between the Palm OS of 1999 and the one in use today and would rather see Apple put its expertise into creating an "end-to-end experience" in a PDA of its own creation.

Mr. Spiers also argues against device convergence in the form of a PDA/MP3 player/camera/cell phone/whatever. While he doesn't like carrying multiple devices when he travels, he sees such an all-in-one gadget "consolidating [bulk] into one bigger lump instead of two or three smaller ones."

Recent Headlines - Updated September 4th

Thu,10:05 PM
Joy of Tech Comic Nails the Difference Between Cable Providers and Customers on Apple TV
6:15 PM
Patriot Ready With a USB-C Flash Drive for Apple’s MacBook
5:20 PM
Apple Committed to ‘Cleaning Up’ Apple Music
5:05 PM
Retailer Screws Up, Shows Off HomeKit Compatible Hue Bridge Early
3:10 PM
Last Chance to Pay What You Want for the Mac Power User Bundle
1:49 PM
TMO Daily Observations 2015-09-03: Apple TV’s Missing Universal Search
12:03 PM
Apple TV Needs Universal Search
10:52 AM
Having Your Own Star Wars BB-8 Droid Really is That Cool
9:37 AM
Judge Koh Slams Attorney Fees in Apple Anti-poaching Settlement
Wed,10:20 PM
ACM 322: Apple’s TV Shows, Ian Rogers’ New Job, iPhone Jailbreaking
5:30 PM
Frozen: How to Force Quit an OS X App Showing a Spinning Beachball of Death
4:40 PM
Making the Case for the iPod Touch
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!