The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
French Amendment Drops Open DRM Requirement

French Amendment Drops Open DRM Requirement

by , 8:10 AM EDT, May 11th, 2006

The controversial copyright bill that would force companies like Apple, Sony, and Microsoft to open their proprietary Digital Rights Management (DRM) copy protection technologies to competitors has been approved by the French Senate with an amendment that offers an avenue to keep the copy protection schemes private. According to Macworld UK, the bill maintained the concept of interoperability, but added a new regulatory agency to mediate requests for details of the various DRM schemes.

The intent of the original bill was to create an open system where portable music players and Internet-based music services all offered compatible products. A Sony Walkman, for example, could play FairPlay protected music downloaded from the iTunes Music Store, and an iPod could play songs downloaded from Naptser.

The new regulatory agency will have the authority to order companies to share the technological details of their DRM schemes with competitors unless the digital music and movie download services can show that they are protecting the content in agreement with the copyright holder. Since the copy protection terms are typically part of distribution contracts, that shouldn't be difficult for Apple, or any other online media distributor, to show.

The amendment also prohibits open source software developers from publishing source code for applications that contain any DRM technology obtained through the law if the original technology developer can show that it would adversely impact the copy protection's effectiveness.

Online music distributors, including Apple, were unhappy with the original bill, fearing that it would erode legitimate online music sales. Apple even referred to the bill as "state sponsored piracy." Had the bill passed in its original form, analysts expected companies to shut down their France-based services to avoid opening their DRM schemes to competitors.

The likelihood that Apple will continue to sell the iPod and operate the iTunes Music Store in France is much greater now that it has some way to protect its FairPlay copy protection. The amendment to the original bill, however, essentially guts the law since companies can refuse to share their DRM schemes.

Observer Comments

Show: Subjects Only | Full Comments
Close Name:Guest
Subject: Going with the flow

Yes well I did wonder how the French were going to deal with the simple fact that if companies like Apple obeyed the French law they would almost certainly be in breach of their agreements with the content suppliers. One presumes Vivendi in particular, no doubt inspired by visions of its DRM'd music floating freely across the airwaves, had a word in the right complient ears and mentioned that the law may well be more obstructive in the long run to French business than helpful. Of course being French they couldn't be seen to kill the Bill so they took the typical Gallic option of effectibely castrating it instead. At least for now.

Close Name:Guest
Subject: that's too bad

The one interesting side effect of this rule had it ever been implemented, Microsoft's DRM would also have to become public knowledge too, finally allowing Apple to get DRM of Windows Media video and audio files on the Mac operating system. One of the biggest ongoing battles preventing Macs from entering the school room and libraries of some counties is the fact that the counties end up deciding on Microsoft's DRM, which has no Mac compatible players without emulation, virtualization or Boot Camp.

Close Name:Guest
Subject: DRM = $#!%

DRM = $#!%

Comment on this Article


You cannot edit your comments.   You cannot delete your comments.

Comments are currently closed. Please email the author instead.


Recent Headlines - Updated March 12th

Fri, 2:30 PM
News - Richard Belzer: Apple Store Employee ‘Was Trying to Shake Me Down’
1:55 PM
How-To - Setting the Ownership of a Shared Mac Disk
1:31 PM
Games - Sam & Max Season 3 Announced; Monkey Island Games Set For Pre-Order
11:48 AM
News - iPad Includes Screen Rotation Lock Feature
11:38 AM
Mac Geek Gab Premium Podcast - MGG 249: Terminal, Backups, Quick Look and More!
11:03 AM
Hidden Dimensions - The Five Problems Apple Faces
10:39 AM
News - Apple Fills in the iPad’s iBooks Blanks
10:10 AM
Hot Forum Topic - iPad Pre-order: Delivery or Reserve?
9:35 AM
News - Apple Details iPad 3G Data Plans
8:52 AM
News - iPad Pre-orders Kick Off with Delivery and Pickup Options
8:36 AM
TMO Appearances - TMO’s John F. Braun Discusses iPad, Geotagging on Mac Roundtable
8:15 AM
News - Apple Store Offline Ahead of iPad Pre-orders

The Mac Observer Reader Specials

  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!