The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

DealsOnTheWeb Daily Deal: Buy.com's After-Christmas Super Store - Check out the Revolving Savings

New Apple iMac Earns C|Net Editors' Choice Award

by , 1:45 PM EDT, August 9th, 2007

C|Net gave the new Apple iMac it's Editors' Choice Award on Wednesday. The iMac was cited for its best-in-class design, solid feeling, thin but solid keyboard, iLife '08, and performance in multimedia benchmarks.

C|Net noted that, regarding the internal hardware, the changes have been simply generational, with new CPU speeds and graphics card updates. Except for extreme gaming, the iMac holds its own. "Now that the Intel-compatible Mac version of Photoshop CS3 is out, Apple can compete on a level playing field with Windows desktops," Rich Brown wrote for C|Net.

"And as expected, the new iMac dominates on Photoshop and on multimedia multitasking, and it also does very well on iTunes and CineBench, the latter as much a measure of overall multicore processing power as it is an indicator of a system's ability to process movie files. Compared to a wide range of competing mainstream desktops, the new Apple iMac more than holds its own, with one typical exception: gaming."


Fourth Generation iMac

C|Net noted that Apple's implementation of 802.11n was a deciding factor in the Editors' Choice Award: "If you spec out a system from any other PC vendor, you'll get within $100 or so of a comparable iMac, but of all the major computer vendors, only Apple offers Draft N wireless in a desktop."

In addition, the keyboard was well received, and the reviewer noted a smooth response that made it a pleasure to type on.

Mr. Brown also had a few complaints. Apple was criticized for not making its upgrade plans more clear regarding Leopard and even went so far as to suggest waiting until October to buy one of the new iMacs when Leopard will be free. Apple's 90 days of phone support was also criticized, and "always feels like a slap in the face when we read it." However, it was pointed out that, as compensation, the Apple community is so strong that it can often make up for that deficiency.

Overall, the iMac received a score of 8.2 out of 10, which is an excellent score for a C|Net review. The final conclusion was notable. "Unless you're a gamer or an upgrade enthusiast, we can think of very few reasons not to make an iMac your next desktop."

  

Observer Comments

Show: Subjects Only | Full Comments
Close Name:Guest
Subject: Future Touch Screen

Aha! The smooth glass cover of the LCD, the black surround, and the included wiping cloth point to just one thing -- future touch-screen iMacs.

Close Name:SiloMunke Posts: 22 Joined: 05 Jul 2006
Subject: Not 4G

This iMac is not the 4th generation of the iMac. This is an update. Look at all the G3 iMacs updates - similar design, but different.

Close Name:Guest
Subject: Why do you want a touch screen

I have a two year old, so my Macbook is alreadya touch screen.

He usually has clean hands, but I am always amazed at how smudgy the screen looks.

I don't want a touch screen, it will always look a mess.

Close Name:gslusher Posts: 2088 Joined: 13 Nov 2002
Subject: Link

Here's the link to the C|Net article.

Close Name:Guest
Subject: it's its

Line 1 of article, "it's" should be "its."

Close Name:Sir Harry Flashman Posts: 792 Joined: 08 Feb 2007
Subject: I tried one again this evening

I stopped in at the Fashion Valley Apple Store this evening and played with the new iMac for quite a bit.

The glossy screen had a good bit of glare from the lighting in the store. For doing graphics that would be a problem. In my home office I am in a bit of a cubby facing out so I really don't have direct light on the screen.

I could get used to the new keyboard fairly quickly, not much of a different feel from my iBook.

I tried the new iLife and I like it. However, I will hold off purchasing it until I find out if it will be included with Leopard.

I looked a Numbers, but didn't try it for very long. From what I see it would meet my needs. I am using Excel, but nothing that is really number crunchy.

More importantly to me I got to try Adobe Creative Suite 3. Well I tried Illustrator and InDesign which I use quite a bit and I like them a lot. I will probably going to upgrade to CS3 within in a few days.

The store was busy and there were a lot of people buying stuff. The iPhone table was quite crowded. Apple's star is on the rise again, the iDog days of summer.

Close Name:Guest
Subject: CNETare quick to award best in class results !

At least they did not test the ease of the sustainable user experience... because they did not have the time to do so. It looks like a race to award honours to things that just came out on the market, with no sustainable feedback. M

aybe this iMac has a flawed architecture, overheats, is noisy... but whatever, CNET needs to be the first to award something... let's take some time to live, sometimes

Close Name:Guest
Subject: touch-screen

Quote
Guest wrote:
Aha! The smooth glass cover of the LCD, the black surround, and the included wiping cloth point to just one thing -- future touch-screen iMacs.


I was equally interested by the inclusion of the "wiping cloth". Is it just a nice little extra (maybe Apple had leftovers from the iPhone?) or will a touch-screen be activated on these Macs once Leopard is out? (The wishing goes on ... )

Close Name:Guest
Subject: New iMac and Leopard update

I called apple and they mentioned if I buy iMac now, I will get and upgrade to Leopard for half price in October. Unless I wait it's free. Half price is better than full.

Close Name:Guest
Subject:

Didn't really mean to imply that I WANTED a touch screen. Just trying to figure out a purpose for the rather unusual "black-eye" around the screen. Cheers

Close Name:Guest
Subject: Glossy Screen

Stopped at NYC Prince street store to check it out, great machine, but i really do NOT like the glossy screen, a TON of glare and reflections. Why did they do this? On my PC I have a LG Flatron Slim monitor (love it!!!) and one of its best features is little to no glare because it is "matte" or flat. I am going to check it out one more time (the iMac, that is) but I think this is a deal breaker, I cant stand glare and reflections esp. as light changes in my apt during the day. I wish I had been in a focus group b/c in about 10 seconds I would have said NO to a highly reflective screen.

Close Name:gslusher Posts: 2088 Joined: 13 Nov 2002
Subject: 4th Generation iMac

Quote
SiloMunke wrote:
This iMac is not the 4th generation of the iMac. This is an update. Look at all the G3 iMacs updates - similar design, but different.


Sure, it is.

1G: iMac G3 (CRT)
2G: iMac G4 (lamp)
3G: iMac G5
4G: iMac Core Duo/Core 2 Duo

You can't be contending that the Intel iMac wasn't a "new generation," regardless of the case design (which was a bit different from the original iMac G5).

Close Name:Guest
Subject: Glossy Screen

The Editor's Choice award for design? You have to be kidding! The iMac's glass screen takes computer design backwards 10 years, to when we had to deal with screen hoods, anti-glare film covers and cowering in dark rooms to diminish the headache-inducing glare. Photo editing is all but impossible on the new iMac because all you see in dark colors is yourself. Professional photographers are left without a Mac in this price range because the glass plate makes proper calibration of the screen impossible. It may be a stunning design, but we measure design by its combination of form and usability. In this regard, the iMac fails.

Comment on this Article


You cannot edit your comments.   You cannot delete your comments.
Log in | Register | Having Problems? Reset TMO Cookies & Try Again
Username:   Password:   Log me on automatically each visit   

You are not logged in, and this post will appear as "Guest." Log in with your username and password from the TMO forums. If you do not have a username, you can register here.
Please note that guests are limited to including a maximum of two URLs per post.


Post A Comment
  Subject


  Your Comments



Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.


Recent Headlines - Updated January 8th

Wed, 6:20 PM
Macworld Expo 2009 - Ecamm Introduces World’s First Bluetooth Webcam
6:16 PM
News - Verbatim Announces Speaker Keyboard, Store ‘n’ Go Micro USB Drive
6:09 PM
Photo Gallery - Photo Gallery: Macworld 2009 Day 2
3:24 PM
Just a Thought - First Time Macworld Impression
12:16 PM
News - EMC Issues Beta of Retrospect 8.0 Backup Software
12:04 PM
News - REAL Server 2009 to Ship Next Month
11:40 AM
News - Livescribe to Bring Pulse Smartpen Software to Mac
10:58 AM
Hot Forum Topic - Reader Reactions: Apple’s Macworld Expo Keynote
10:39 AM
News - Verbatim, Lexar Introduce New Flash Storage Options
10:20 AM
Editorial - Don’t shoot the messenger: Content, Not Delivery Marred Apple’s Last Keynote
9:51 AM
News - LaCie Releases 2big Quadra External Hard Drive Line
9:29 AM
News - Microsoft’s Mac Business Unit Reveals Upcoming Office Improvements

The Mac Observer Reader Specials