Featured Article: TMO Quick Tip - Smart Mailboxes: Organize Mail by Date
Evaluating Windows, Mac OS X and Linux Based on Trust
by , 4:10 PM EDT, October 16th, 2007
There are times when it may be appropriate to select Linux over Mac OS X and Windows based on the principle of trust, according to Low End Mac on Monday.
Keith Winston, a convert to Mac OS X from Linux, and knowledgeable of Linux, spoke of some of the metrics which, on occasion, might dictate the use of Linux over Mac OS X, namely flexibility, security and trust. Specific applications cited were dedicated servers and high security applications that require the user to have complete understanding and control of the OS.
Evaluating security amongst the three OSes is difficult, perhaps more of an art than a science. "If you start with the operating system, you can look at past history, the number of known exploits, the severity of known exploits, and the malware ecosystem. You have to account for the out of the box configuration, included software and services, encryption options, and the ability to apply patches. Then there's the hardware -- physical security and locking options, processor and architecture exploits, portability. It can be mind numbing," Mr. Winston wrote.
However, in the specific scenario of user trust derived from a completely open source system, Linux has the advantage.
Mr. Winston worked his through the OS options and gave examples. In the case of Windows, there is the recent fiasco with the Stealth Patch Incident. In this incident, Microsoft updated Windows regardless of their stated preference setting. It raised the question of who was in control of the computer. In addition, the Windows Product Activation feature can unilaterally disable a Windows computer if piracy is suspected.
In the case of Mac OS X, which has an open source FreeBSD UNIX core called Darwin, there is still plenty of proprietary code overlaid on top. "I love using Macs (I'm banging this article out on a Mac)," Mr. Winston noted. "...but there are two things that limit my ultimate trust. One is the lack of open source for the some parts of the system, and the second is the track record of Apple toward users. Without complete source, I can't be reasonably sure that Apple won't force a Windows-style stealth patch someday. In fact, I am reasonably sure they have the ability to do so."
Finally, there is Linux which is completely open source. "I can be certain that no patches will be applied unless I permit it. I can control precisely the software I want to run and can remove any software I don't want to run. I have complete access to all source code, along with many other people, so security issues can be found and fixed quickly," Mr. Winston concluded.
"There is no phoning home and no unlicensed software by definition. I can use encryption algorithms that have stood the test of time and proven strong. I have a strong level of confidence in every part of the system - I trust it, even connected to the big, bad Internet."
TMO notes that Apple has pointed out to its customers that the resulting tinkerability of Linux is good for individuals in companies, but not always so good for the company as a whole because it can lead to out-of-configuration systems. So, for competitive and ease-of-use reasons, Mac OS X has proprietary code. However, for those occasions when the users must certify their complete control over the OS, in critical server applications and security research, Linux looks like the best solution to Mr. Winston.
Observer Comments
Tue Oct 16, 2007 8:00 pm Subject: I think choice is king...
I think it is great for MO to provide differing opinions! I have worked with all 3 systems and really enjoy and promote Linux as a server. As the author mentioned, I like the functionality of Mac + all the underpinnings of Unix. SSH rules as does terminal and applescript.
I really really want windows to some how stop being a huge pain in the patoot. It is just frustrating to work on. I am going to beat a dead horse here, but I am constantly amazed and frustrated with the nearly continual support I provide my family members with their windows machines.
My father in law recently purchased a MacBook Even though I have repeatedly mention that I can provide him any help he may need, I have yet to hear from him. So, either it is working great or he cannot get it connected at all!
Having a differing opinion is not always a bad thing. For some folks, it always is.
Wed Oct 17, 2007 8:58 am Subject: TMO ain't perfect...
I have to say, compared to some of the front page pieces I've personally taken exception with (mostly IPO stories spilling over into the TMO side), this is actually pretty interesting (if a little obvious) and relevant to Macs and Macintosh news. For a "free" site I think we get a pretty consistent level of quality from TMO, warts and all.
I'm sure nobody will miss you guest, as you obviously can't be bothered to register an actual name on the site, or login to post from it if you do have one.
Wed Oct 17, 2007 9:59 am Subject:
QuoteAnonymous wrote:
Haven't bothered visiting in many weeks. Kind of disappointing to see this useless opinion crap still being pushed on your visitors. Oh well. And to think this used to be my main Apple-related site for years! Well, back to the other news/rumor sites for me!
Sorry you feel that way, Biff.
QuoteIntruder wrote:QuoteAnonymous wrote:
Haven't bothered visiting in many weeks. Kind of disappointing to see this useless opinion crap still being pushed on your visitors. Oh well. And to think this used to be my main Apple-related site for years! Well, back to the other news/rumor sites for me!
Sorry you feel that way, Biff.
Feeling sorry doesn't solve anything. He's right about what he's saying. I can see that already. You won't hunt Biff to the ends of the earth, will you?
Fri Oct 19, 2007 5:57 pm Subject:
QuoteFairly wrote:QuoteIntruder wrote:QuoteAnonymous wrote:
Haven't bothered visiting in many weeks. Kind of disappointing to see this useless opinion crap still being pushed on your visitors. Oh well. And to think this used to be my main Apple-related site for years! Well, back to the other news/rumor sites for me!
Sorry you feel that way, Biff.
Feeling sorry doesn't solve anything. He's right about what he's saying. I can see that already. You won't hunt Biff to the ends of the earth, will you?
What are you on about? Biff has been a long-term member here (since 2004). I am sorry to see him decide to go elsewhere.
As the saying goes: Sometimes a cigar is just a cigar.
Recent Headlines - Updated Tuesday, July 8th, 2008
- Tue., 6:55 PM
- User Friendly Blog by Ted Landau - Why User Interface Design Matters
- 4:30 PM
- Apple Trackpad Secrets and Technical History
- 4:05 PM
- iPodObserver - Apple: What to Bring When Buying iPhone 3G
- 3:35 PM
- Microsoft: We Have a Noisy Competitor
- 2:50 PM
- Columnist: Safari Security Fails to Learn from Past
- 2:20 PM
- iPodObserver - Services to Unlock Mobile Phones Gaining Momentum
- 1:00 PM
- Daylite 3.7.4 Adds iWork 08, Dialectic Integration
- 12:20 PM
- FoneLink 2.1 Adds Support for More Cell Phones
- 11:25 AM
- Freeway 5.1.3 Adds Chinese Support
- 11:10 AM
- iPodObserver - Rumor: Canadian Apple Stores Won't Sell iPhone 3G
- 10:35 AM
- Microsoft Aligns with Icahn for Yahoo Takeover
- 10:00 AM
- Hot Forum Topic - Is Internet Killing the Video Star?
- 8:20 AM
- iPodObserver - MobileMe Launches on July 10
- 7:55 AM
- iPodObserver - Apple: iPhone 3G Launches at 8AM Friday
- 6:00 AM
- iPO Review - BudFits
The Mac Observer Reader Specials
- Download Typestyler, still the Ultimate Styling Tool for Internet, Print and Video Graphics. Works great in Classic with a Native OS X Version on the way. Free Tryout: www.typestyler.com
- OWC: Upgrade to a Larger Hard Drive, Add Additional Drives SATA for Mac Pro and G5s, up to 1.0TB in each Bay. 500GB from $90!
MacPro Memory 667Mhz With Apple Spec Heat Sink 2GB $90 / 4GB $134 / 8GB $264. Click to Maximize your Macs...
Mac observers can now play Party Poker for Mac as well as Mac casino games by going to MacPokerOnline.com.
RamJet Memory: MacBook 1Gig $39, 2Gig $78, 4Gig $195! Mac Pro 2Gig $115, 4Gig $189! 500G Seagate SATA II $139! Click hereFor the latest Apple products use Ciao a comparison website to find laptops like MacBook Air. Then find the best prices on MP3 players and use our comparison tool to evaluate cell phones.
Laptop Hardware Provided by TechRestore - Overnight Mac & iPod Repairs.

