Psystar Might Try Antitrust Defense
Psystar Might Try Antitrust Defense
by , 1:55 PM EDT, August 4th, 2008
Psystar's legal defense team plans to roll out antitrust issues if the Apple case against them goes to trial, according to Computerworld on Monday. At issue is whether Apple has exclusive rights to Mac OS X.
One of the attorneys with Carr & Ferrell LLP, representing Psystar, Colby Springer said, "This case has been mischaracterized. There are a lot more complicated issues than just copyright or trademark. There are more complex issues ... in respect to the end-user licensing agreement. And antitrust issues come into play, too."
Apple's End User License Agreement, EULA, says: "You agree not to install, use or run the Apple software on any non-Apple-labeled computer, or to enable others to do so."
Some attorneys who specialize in antitrust cases, including Carr & Ferrel itself believe that Apple would face antitrust issues if the case goes to trial. "What Psystar might say is, 'What we would like to do is use the Mac operating system's unique features more broadly on a variety of hardware'," according to Carole Handler with Wildman, Harrold, Allen & Dixon.
TMO notes that Apple and other attorneys disagree. Apple hasn't been declared a monopoly by any stretch of the imagination, so what remains is Apple's patent and copyright protection of its intellectual property. That could be a much more tenable argument that simply insisting that Psystar would like to break up a non-declared monopoly in order to seize a share of Apple's revenue. If a judge sees it that way, Psystar might be compelled to reimburse all its customers for their purchases, effectively putting them put out of business.
Observer Comments
I find it hard to believe that any court could find the manufacturer of an OS that holds 10% or less of the market to be in violation of antitrust rules. Yes, OS-X has some features that Windows doesn't have. And Windows has features that OS-X doesn't. And Ubuntu does things that neither of them will do. This sounds like a desperate strategy because they don?t have anything else.
On the other hand we ARE talking about the US justice system so anything could happen.
Mon Aug 04, 2008 2:51 pm Subject: Claim Jumpers
Mon Aug 04, 2008 3:19 pm Subject: gonna force this are they?
Well, Apple could just as easily (turn of phrase, not necessarily evaluated for practicality) move the entire OS back onto the ROM chip and wipe out the whole "software" issue. I the the OS is part of the hardware, and only Apple has access to the hardware, it would pretty much make moot Psystar's dying grasp at a straw here.
Would Apple do such a thing? I doubt it. OS on ROM is passe. It's so 2 decades ago. Apple has been allowed to control the widget now for 20 years, give or take the brief flirtation with clones in the 90s that turned into an unmitigated flop.
I think a judge or panel of them will see that this is nothing more than a revenue stealing ploy, trying to cash in at another's expense, without their permission, or any sort of licensing agreement. It will end up costing Psystar their business for their lack of vision and unwillingness to do something of their own accord instead of "borrowing" (I didn't say stealing) somebody else's ideas.
I can't see Psystar winning although it was bound to happen eventually since Apple is using PC components. Hopefully after this is over and Apple wins, I'd almost bet that the challenges and claims Psystar makes will only make Apple improve their defense and make their EULA, copyrights, trademarks and patents that much more impenetrable. Once the new chip designs with P.A. Semi and the improved ARM designs it should be more difficult for Psystar to offer these "counterfeit" Macs as I see 'em!
Apple could also chose not to sell OSX as an upgrade at all or only to people who can prove they have bought a previous Mac before. Apple could also implement tiered pricing.
QuoteTiger wrote:
Well, Apple could just as easily (turn of phrase, not necessarily evaluated for practicality) move the entire OS back onto the ROM chip and wipe out the whole "software" issue. I the the OS is part of the hardware, and only Apple has access to the hardware, it would pretty much make moot Psystar's dying grasp at a straw here.
Would Apple do such a thing? I doubt it. OS on ROM is passe. It's so 2 decades ago. Apple has been allowed to control the widget now for 20 years, give or take the brief flirtation with clones in the 90s that turned into an unmitigated flop.
I think a judge or panel of them will see that this is nothing more than a revenue stealing ploy, trying to cash in at another's expense, without their permission, or any sort of licensing agreement. It will end up costing Psystar their business for their lack of vision and unwillingness to do something of their own accord instead of "borrowing" (I didn't say stealing) somebody else's ideas.
I would speculate that this won't go to trial, that psystar will stop selling their clones, and that there will be a non-disclosure agreement in the settlement thereby leaving us all in the dark as to what "really" happened.
End result, Apple retains rights to its intellectual property, and psystar closes its doors.
I think psystar is like a tick landing itself on a large dog. Yes, the tick gets fed, grows larger, gets noticed, gets removed and squashed.
Comments are currently closed. Please email the author instead.
Recent Headlines - Updated November 8th
- Sat, 7:58 PM
- News - Apple TV 3.0.1 Update Fixes Missing Content Bug
- Fri, 7:45 PM
- Rumor - Taiwan Leak Shows Verizon UTMS/CDMA iPhone for Q3 2010
- 6:40 PM
- News - iPhone Moves Into RadioShack
- 6:30 PM
- News - Apple to Open Stunning Paris Apple Store in Le Louvre on Saturday
- 5:43 PM
- Free on iTunes - Dictionary, Dictionary, Dictionary, And More
- 4:09 PM
- John Martellaro's Blog - Particle Debris (week ending 11/6) Failure IS an Option
- 3:32 PM
- Games - The Latest App Store Games: Gravity Sling, RocketBird, Ground Effect, Checkers!
- 2:25 PM
- Games - Star Soccer 2010 for Mac Puts Gamers in Role of Up-and-Coming Player
- 2:15 PM
- How-To - The Mysteries of Rosetta Housekeeping
- 1:33 PM
- News - iPhone Game Developer Sued for Collecting User’s Cell Numbers
- 1:17 PM
- Games - Warhammer Online Expands Trial Play Option
- 11:19 AM
- Rumor - Apple May Be Bringing RFID to the iPhone
The Mac Observer Reader Specials
- TypeStyler For Mac OS X is Now Shipping! Download The Free Fully Functional 60 Day Tryout at www.typestyler.com
RamJet Memory: Mac Pro 8-core 8GB Kit $199.99, 4GB Kits $109.99! Sale on MacBook and MacBook Pro 8GB kits $549.99! New MacBook DDR3 2GB for $49.99. iMac and Mac mini 4GB Kits for $79.99! 1TB SATA Hard Drives for $109.99! Click here
OWC: Get the Right Memory for Your Mac Top Quality, Competitive Price, Lifetime Backed Free Expert Support + Installation Videos too! MacBook & mini 8GB, iMac 16GB, Mac Pro up to 32GB. Click here
If you're using a Mac, then you've gotta check out Full Tilt Poker for Mac. This Full Tilt Poker bonus code does the unthinkable, it actually rewards!For the latest Apple products use Ciao, a price comparison website, to find laptops like MacBook Air. Then find the best prices on MP3 players and use our comparison tool to evaluate mobile phones like the Apple iPhone.
Laptop Hardware Provided by TechRestore - Overnight Mac & iPod Repairs.

