The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
CNET: Key to Windows 7 Success is Geeks

CNET: Key to Windows 7 Success is Geeks

by , 3:05 PM EDT, September 22nd, 2008

The way to maintain the reputation of an OS is to make it appeal to the resident geeks because they are the ones who make or break its reputation, according to Don Reisinger at CNET on Monday. Microsoft didn't do that with Vista, but Apple did with Mac OS X.

The downfall of Vista was that while Microsoft tried to build its appeal for the average consumer, its inability to satisfy the geeks created unexpected issued.

"throughout the past year, those stories written by geeks for geeks were littered with criticisms of Vista and countless reasons why the company made mistakes," Mr. Reisinger wrote. He described the trickle down effect:

"... a tech company screws up a product in ways that the tech-savvy crowd will notice, but the mainstream crowd won't," he continued. "Once that happens, geeks start railing on the product and discuss why it's so bad. Eventually, they start complaining to their family and friends, who don't know much about it and the distaste for products starts entering the mainstream. Once that happens, those people will start talking to others and soon it becomes viral."

It's important that Microsoft not make the same mistake with Windows 7, but the author isn't sure Microsoft can do it. "The one thing I don't understand about Microsoft and countless other companies in the technology industry is why they don't realize that the influential people are not the average John and Jane Doe," Mr. Reisinger explained. "Instead, the technology industry is dominated by a select few that tell their friends and family why a certain product or service is useless."

Therefore, making Windows 7 even more appealing to the consumer won't help if the Geeks aren't happy. "...if Microsoft wants Windows 7 to be a success, it better create a product that appeals to that niche and start playing nice with it. If it doesn't, look for Microsoft's PR troubles to continue indefinitely," the author concluded.

TMO notes that Apple doesn't have that problem with Mac OS X. UNIX geeks can play with core elements like LDAP, communication sockets, Bash, X11, NFS, open source, and UNIX daemons to their heart's content, but the average user sees none of that as they read their e-mail and surf the Web.

Recent Headlines - Updated October 21st

Tue,8:51 PM
GTAT Announces ‘Amicable Parting’ of Ways with Apple
6:50 PM
How I Came to Own and Sell a TAM Probably Owned by Jony Ive
5:01 PM
Adobe KnowHow: Learn Photography From The Best for $29.99
4:49 PM
How To Get Ready For iOS 8.1 [Update]
2:59 PM
Chuck La Tournous and Chris Breen to Speak at NJMUG’s 30th Anniversary Tuesday
2:24 PM
Don’t Upgrade to Yosemite or iOS 8.1 Before You Read This Column
2:06 PM
TMO Daily Observations: 2014-10-21
12:29 PM
How Apple Pay Mitigates Breach Fatigue
10:50 AM
How to Enable Apple’s SMS Relay on your Mac or iPad
9:43 AM
Apple Earnings Smackdown Ranks Analyst Predictions
Mon,9:52 PM
Apple Q4 Earnings Sliced And Diced
8:21 PM
Apple Q4 MacBook Sales Hit Record Breaking Numbers, Jump 25 Percent
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!