The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

Featured Article: Podcast - Apple Weekly Report #124: New iMacs, Apple Lawsuits, RIP GoLive & Speaker Reviews

 
Dr. Mac: Rants & Raves - "Interesting" Looking Hardware

by
February 16th, 2007

Episode #74

I'm a sucker for an interesting hardware design. Unfortunately, there aren't that many Mac products that exhibit interesting or unique designs. Aside from almost anything designed by Apple, the pickings can be slim. That said, I've been collecting pictures of hardware products with interesting design characteristics ever since Macworld in January, so here are some of my faves:

A product that not only caught my eye at Macworld Expo, but made me go back and see it two more times ‘cause I wasn't sure I believed my eyes, was the ModBook Tablet from Axiotron and Other World Computing.

Andreas Haas, president of Axiotron, said, "Built for mobile users, artists, students, medical practitioners and professionals, the Axiotron ModBook enables its user to draw and write directly on the screen, while the handwriting recognition built into Mac OS X Tiger not only turns hand scribbles into text in every application, but also provides extended control of the system through gesture recognition. If your favored input device is the pen, then this is the Mac tablet solution for you."


The Modbook Tablet is a flat touch-screen stylus-driven Mac.
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

The ModBook is an after-market mash-up of an Apple MacBook notebook computer and a Wacom pen tablet, but as you can see, it is beautifully designed. I watched an artist sketching on it and it seemed very natural to her. I don't think I'd like using it much, but as Haas said, if you favor a Wacom tablet, this may be just the computer for you. Various configurations start at $2,279.

Another thing that caught my eye at Macworld were these two different types of mushroom-shaped multimedia speakers from JBL. Both flavors (groan) are available in several fashionable colors and both were made up of a mushroom-like sub woofer and a pair of smaller satellites, as shown below.

 


Two different types of mushroom-like speaker systems from JBL.
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

It was hard to tell how either system sounded in the din of the main show hall, but they both looked pretty sweet to me.

My vote for most unique iPod accessory I've seen goes to the Juke Box Station from Saffire Products, an interesting take on the old time jukebox, but with a dock connector.


The Juke Box Station from Saffire.
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

Again, it was hard to determine how the thing actually sounded on the noisy show floor at Macworld, but like the JBL speakers above, the Juke Box Station looks pretty marvelous. 

Moving right along, my vote for the absolute crappiest iPod product I have ever seen goes to the iPod toilet paper holder.

 


It's an iPod toilet paper holder. No kidding.
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

I'm rarely rendered speechless but this thing did just that. And while I couldn't speak for a few moments, the whole time I was wondering, "what the hell were they thinking?" Do you think anyone in their right mind would pay good money for this?

Now this one is an oldie, but it's a goodie... They called it Hubzilla and it was a 4-port FireWire 400 hub that is modeled after (you guessed it) Godzilla. Hubzilla is no longer available (as far as I can tell), but it sure was one wacky-looking device.


This is Hubzilla... (What else could you possibly call it?)
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

Last but not least, there's one company other than Apple that comes to mind any time I think about hardware products with interesting designs and that company is LaCie. I've bought a couple of their hard drives designed by F.A. Porsche as shown here:


LaCie hard disk designed by F.A. Porsche
photo courtesy of LaCie
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

It's not fancy or high-concept but it strikes me as a perfect example of understated elegance. And since the Porsche drives cost about the same as less stylish drives from other vendors, there's no disincentive to buying the better looking (IMHO) LaCie drives when I need more storage.

Beyond the Porsche drives, which I consider subtle, I like that LaCie has both a sense of style and a sense of humor about its designs. Take the LaCie Brick hard drives, for example. Designed by "the world-famous designer Ora-Ďto," they look like big old Lego blocks.


LaCie Brick drives look like big Legos.
photo courtesy of LaCie
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

Two more examples of LaCie's interesting and playful designs are the new FireWire speakers and USB/FireWire hub, both introduced at Macworld Expo.


LaCie's interesting new FireWire speakers.
photo courtesy of LaCie
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.


LaCie's wacky-looking USB/FireWire hub.
photo courtesy of LaCie
(Click the thumbnail for a larger image.)

So there you have them... some hardware designs I find interesting. These are my opinions so please don't write to tell me I'm wrong. On the other hand, if you know of a cool or interesting product design that wasn't included in this column,  please let me know about it and perhaps we can do this again someday.

And that's all he wrote...

Bob "Dr. Mac" LeVitus has been a Macintosh user for a long, long time and has written 49 computer books including Mac OS X Tiger For Dummies and GarageBand for Dummies. He also offers expert technical help and training to Mac users, in real time and at reasonable prices, via telephone, e-mail, and/or unique Internet-enabled remote control software. For more information on Bob and his services, visit www.boblevitus.com.

Send polite comments to

Send impolite comments to DeleteWithoutReading@boblevitus.com, or post your comments below.

Dr. Mac: Rants & Raves Archives.

Digg!

Observer Comments

Show: Subjects Only | Full Comments
Close Name:mahuti -   TMO Staff Posts: 363 Joined: 09 Jan 2003
Subject: No doubt...

No doubt about it, that last one is certainly "interesting." Looks somewhat useless though. Speaking of which, some of my useless cash may have to spend itself on hubzilla.

Close Name:DoctorMac Posts: 32 Joined: 16 Oct 2006
Subject: Hubzilla may be hard to find...

Mahuti,

You may have trouble finding Hubzilla today... it was available around 5 years ago and I couldn’t find a vendor still selling them when I researched the article. Fortunately I had that picture stashed away from a long time ago.

I hope you have better luck finding one than I did.

Close Name:geoduck Posts: 1662 Joined: 30 Dec 2003
Subject:

Personally I liked the Tiki USB Drive
http://www.everythingusb.com/news/index/6493.htm

I'm not sure it's available any more (TikiMac does not seem to be on the web any longer), but it was fun.

Close Name:mahuti -   TMO Staff Posts: 363 Joined: 09 Jan 2003
Subject: oh well

easy come easy go

Close Name:Jonkun227 Posts: 238 Joined: 02 Mar 2004
Subject:

I just think it's funny that this is the 2nd or 3rd time this year I've read something from you and you've stated that you're rarely rendered speechless.

Seems to be a common occurrence after all.


- Jon

Close Name:Rainy Day Posts: 607 Joined: 07 Jun 2005
Subject: You forgot one…

You forgot one: The The Power Squid.

Close Name:mklprc Posts: 1 Joined: 17 Feb 2007
Subject: The LaCie "Porsche-designed" Yugo drive

I call those drives the Yugo in honor of the cheap Yugoslavian-made car that was one of the cheapest, worst cars ever imported into the USA. The "Yugo" drive is LaCie's worst product. It easily overheats, damaging the industry-standard drive inside; is shipped and sold in Mac stores pre-formatted for Microsoft, which shreds any data saved to it, should it ever be moved from an OS9 Mac to an OSX Mac, or vice-versa. Every box should bear a large red label, "WARNING - REFORMAT BEFORE USING OR YOU WILL LOSE YOUR DATA" and "NEVER COVER CASE - EXTREMELY SENSITIVE TO HEAT BUILDUP." I don't think they even use the Rockwell chipset. Their other drives, the D2 and the Ruggedized cases are good products, but avoid the Yugo for anything important. No opinion on the Lego cases; I have never run into someone who owns one.

Close Name:DoctorMac Posts: 32 Joined: 16 Oct 2006
Subject: Re: The LaCie "Porsche-designed" Yugo drive

mklprc,

This is my third Porsche design hard disk. All three are working flawlessly and have worked that way since the day they arrived. Two of the three are over 2 years old. None has ever overheated.

So my experience with them has been completely positive and I wouldn't call them "Yugos" at all. To me they've been much more like Volkswagens or MiniCoopers -- reasonably priced and decently made.

Close Name:gslusher Posts: 2001 Joined: 13 Nov 2002
Subject:

Quote
mklprc wrote:
I call those drives the Yugo in honor of the cheap Yugoslavian-made car that was one of the cheapest, worst cars ever imported into the USA. The "Yugo" drive is LaCie's worst product. It easily overheats, damaging the industry-standard drive inside; is shipped and sold in Mac stores pre-formatted for Microsoft, which shreds any data saved to it, should it ever be moved from an OS9 Mac to an OSX Mac, or vice-versa. Every box should bear a large red label, "WARNING - REFORMAT BEFORE USING OR YOU WILL LOSE YOUR DATA" and "NEVER COVER CASE - EXTREMELY SENSITIVE TO HEAT BUILDUP." I don't think they even use the Rockwell chipset. Their other drives, the D2 and the Ruggedized cases are good products, but avoid the Yugo for anything important. No opinion on the Lego cases; I have never run into someone who owns one.


Any evidence of this, other than personal anecdotes? Drive reliabilty can really be tested only with a farily large number of cases. Do you have a reference to a study or analysis of the drives?

It might be interesting to you that the only hard drive that I've had that has failed was a LaCie D2. It first would not wake up after sleeping, then wouldn't mount unless the Mac was restarted, then failed completely with a clicking sound.

For what it's worth, the instructions that come with the Porsche drives do say to reformat the drive in HFS+ to use with Macs (especially OS X). The instructions also say:

"* Do not block the ventilation outlets on the rear of the drive. These help to keep your drive cool during operation. Blocking the ventilation outlets may cause damage to your drive and cause an increased risk of short-circuiting or fire.

* Do not expose the hard drive to temperatures outside the range of 5° C to 35° C (41° F to 95° F) in operating mode. Doing so may damage the drive or disfigure its casing. Avoid placing your drive near a source of heat or exposing it to sunlight (even through a window). Inversely, placing your drive in an environment that is too cold or humid may damage the unit. Because of heat issues, LaCie recommends that users do not stack more than three drives together. When stacking three drives, environment temperature should not exceed 30°C (86°F)."

Of course, there are probably many people who don't bother reading instructions, perhaps because they think that they know everything.

---


EDIT: Add this:

The manual for the D2 Extreme (triple interface) drives has this:

"Caution! The LaCie Big Disk Extreme with Triple Interface utilizes the aluminum alloy casing to help dissipate heat. There are important location consideration precautions to keep in mind when setting up your drive. Make sure to place your drive in a well ventilated space, do not block the ventilation outlet on the back of the drive and keep the area in front of the drive unobstructed to allow for proper airflow. If you will be stacking or racking your drive, please follow these considerations:

* When stacking drives, place no more than three drives on top of each other.

* When stacking drives, make sure and adhere the rubber feet to the bottom of the drives.

* When racking drives in the LaCie Desk Rack (sold separately), place no more than three drives in the rack.

* When racking in 19” equipment racks, only rack the equipment in a regulated, air-conditioned room, keep cables and other obstructions away from the rear of the drive and do not place more than three drives on top of each other."

So, according to LaCie, the stacking restrictions are the same for the D2 and Porsche drives.



Last edited by gslusher on Sun Feb 18, 2007 4:36 pm; edited 1 time in total
Reply | Quote
View Name:Guest
Subject: Article byline credits Bryan Chaffin and not Dr. Mac?
View Name:Guest
Subject:
Close Name:DoctorMac Posts: 32 Joined: 16 Oct 2006
Subject: speechless?

If you knew how much I talk you'd know that being rendered speechless two or three times a year makes it quite rare.

Close Name:gslusher Posts: 2001 Joined: 13 Nov 2002
Subject: New report on disk failures

Quote
mklprc wrote:
NEVER COVER CASE - EXTREMELY SENSITIVE TO HEAT BUILDUP.


Read this report:

"Contrary to previously reported results, we found very little correlation between failure rates and either elevated temperature or activity levels."

View Name:Guest
Subject:
Close Name:sleepygeek -   TMO Forum Mod Posts: 4138 Joined: 17 Jan 2006
Subject: Re: New report on disk failures

Quote
"Contrary to previously reported results, we found very little correlation between failure rates and either elevated temperature or activity levels."
Hard drives have to recalibrate their behaviour for even a half degree change in temperature; they are extremely temperature sensitive. The report you quote is, I believe, based on 24/7 use in a server, probably in air conditioned surroundings. It is the constancy of the ambient temperature and absence of power-offs that allows these drives to be reliable at high temperature. This does not apply to desktop and external drives. Frequent power cycles with immediate operation from cold and during a 1-2 hour warm up, in varying ambient temperature, mean that high temperature running is definitely a source of unreliability. You will frequently find such a drive dies unexpectedly when switched on one morning when it is no longer able to do initial calibaration. Frequently, simply leaving it powered up for an hour or two to get hot, then powering off and on, will revive it sufficiently to complete calibration and recover your data.

Sustained high temperatures always lead to earlier component failure, but if, despite running hot, the drive is within the manufacturer's specified temperature range, these accelerated failures will not be statistically significant within the service life of the drive (the manufacturer's quoted life before it is mechanically worn out). failures beyond the end of the service life are not included in reliability (MTBF) figures.

Comment on this Article


You cannot edit your comments.   You cannot delete your comments.
Log in | Register | Having Problems? Reset TMO Cookies & Try Again
Username:   Password:   Log me on automatically each visit   

You are not logged in, and this post will appear as "Guest." Log in with your username and password from the TMO forums. If you do not have a username, you can register here.
Please note that guests are limited to including a maximum of two URLs per post.


Post A Comment
  Subject


  Your Comments



Please enter the word exactly as you see it in the image above. Registered users aren't prompted for this. Having trouble reading the image get a new one.


Recent Headlines - Updated Monday, May 12th, 2008

Mon., 8:40 AM
Pixelmator 1.2 Draftsman Adds Rulers, Adjustments
8:15 AM
iPhone Unavailable at US, UK Apple Store
8:00 AM
iPO Ted Landau's User Friendly View - In search of headphones for my iPhone
7:30 AM
iPO Quick Tip - iPhone: Saving SMS Messages to Your Mac
Fri., 6:00 PM
iPO Free on iTunes - Aussie UFOs, StrangeThings, Hometown Tales and More
5:30 PM
StrangeCharm - Fewer Particles, More Debris ( Week of May 5)
4:05 PM
MW: The New Rules for Buying a Mac
3:15 PM
OpenOffice 3.0 beta Released for Mac OS X
1:30 PM
Pogue: Time Capsule is So Simple, Just Ignore It
1:05 PM
C|Net: Why Apple Should Build a Game Console
10:45 AM
Hot Forum Topic - The iPhone's March Across the World
10:20 AM
Mailplane 2 Beta Includes OmniFocus Support
9:45 AM
iPodObserver - Apple Canada Offers $45 Credit in iPod Suit
9:05 AM
Apple Settles Power Adapter Suit
8:05 AM
Microsoft Dissolves Yahoo Proxy Board
7:30 AM
TMO Quick Tip - Tracking Application Updates in Dashboard
 

The Mac Observer Reader Specials

Apple Stock Quote

  • AAPL: $183.45. Change Today: 0.00.
  • (Prices delayed up to 20 minutes.)
  • Discuss in our Apple Finance Board

Hot Topics

Top Deals From DealsOnTheWeb