The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Drive Genius 1.5.1

Review - Drive Genius 1.5.1

by , 9:00 AM EST, January 2nd, 2007

Keeping your hard drive healthy is a critical part in making sure you Mac stays trouble-free. Drive Genius from Prosoft Engineering takes care of several aspects of this job in a single easy to use application.

Drive Genius offers a pretty extensive features set: It supports PowerPC and Intel-based Macs, it fixes a slew of issues that otherwise would keep your Mac from working, formats and partitions disks, performs disk diagnostics and benchmarks, defragments files, clones disks, and securely deletes documents. Booting from the Drive Genius CD works on PowerPC and Intel-based Macs, too.


Drive Genius

Most people probably look to Drive Genius when they need to fix their Mac when it stops booting, gets super sluggish, or when applications crash far too often. Its disk repair tools include disk structure, volume headers, volume bit maps, directory rebuilding, and repairing permissions. It also performs volume structure tests.


Drive Genius includes a disk repair option.

Formatting and repartitioning hard drives is something you can already do with Apple's Disk Utility application, but Drive Genius handles those tasks with a bit more flexibility. Prosoft's utility also lets you resize and shift partitions on-the-fly so you don't lose the data that's already on your disk. Even though I didn't have any issues when I repartitioned my test drive, I recommend you backup your data before using these features.

If you suspect your drive may have a mechanical problem, or you just want to see how its performance stacks up against other drives, Drive Genius can help. It includes a test to scan for bad blocks, checks the drive mechanism, performs long term read and write integrity checks, and benchmarks your drive's performance. Internal drives that support S.M.A.R.T., or built-in monitoring that watches to see if your drive is getting ready to fail, get checked, too.

Unfortunately, you can't check the S.M.A.R.T. status of external drives. The blame for that one falls on Apple's shoulders: Mac OS X does not support S.M.A.R.T status checks on USB and FireWire-connected drives.

There was a time when defragmenting, or optimizing, Mac OS X drives was generally considered to be a bad thing. But now even Apple recommends defragmenting your drive once a year. Despite my fears that defragmenting would result in lost data and a drive that no longer booted (a fear from the early days of Mac OS X when I watched defraggers break symlink after symlink, destroying the operating system), I tested this feature, too - but not on my primary boot drive, of course.


Each component includes a simple interface.

Much to my surprise and delight, Drive Genius rejoined every file that was split across the drive, and left it bootable, too. I can finally feel comfortable recommending a disk defragger again. I haven't been able to do that since the old days of Mac OS 9.

Novice users, however, may have trouble finding some of the Drive Genius features. For some, you need to click the Volumes tab first. For others, you need to click the Devices tab. The groupings will make sense to More seasoned users, but others will likely get confused trying to figure out which features go along with each tab.

The Bottom Line
Drive Genius is a reliable, friendly disk maintenance suite with tools for the novice and advanced user alike. It includes the disk repair and diagnosing tools that everyone needs, and throws in some nice bonuses like on-the-fly repartitioning and drive benchmarking, too. I firmly believe in keeping a couple disk repair applications handy, and Drive Genius is always within arm's reach.

Digg!


Product: Drive Genius 1.5.1

Company: Prosoft Engineering

List Price: $99

4 out of 5 stars

Pros: Plenty of tools in one package, does its job well.
Cons: A few features may take some work to find.

Observer Comments

Show: Subjects Only | Full Comments
Close Name:brett_x Posts: 322 Joined: 24 Jan 2006
Subject: nothing like Norton

For some reason, no disk utility has ever worked as reliably as Norton Disk Doctor used to work back in OS 9 and early OS X days. Drive Genius is no exception. It does work well, I can say, but I do miss NDD.
That aside, Drive Genius does have an enterprise license available.. for about $250. So if you manage a whole lot of macs (or even just a few), it is great to have a fully legal disk utility for so little.

Close Name:revry Posts: 6 Joined: 25 Aug 2005
Subject: Use Caution with Drive Genius

Using Drive Genius last year, I inadvertently wiped out an external hard drive by accidentally "installing" the program on it.

There are a lot of nice features to the program, but do be careful with it.

Close Name:Rainy Day Posts: 607 Joined: 07 Jun 2005
Subject: Just ain’t so

After NDD royally hosed up a troubled but mountable MacOS 9 disk i had (and rendered it completely unmountable), i threw it in the trash where it belonged and bought Disk Warrior. I was eventually able to recover the disk by manually editing the Volume Table of Contents to get the disk to mount. From that point on Disk Warrior was able to completely heal the drive.

As for Drive Genius, i have never used it, but much of it sounds superfluous. Such as defragmenting. Tiger automatically defragments most files.

Quote
Jeff Gamet wrote:
now even Apple recommends defragmenting your drive once a year.

Really? Where? I can’t imagine why, since Tiger already does this.

Quote
Jeff Gamet wrote:
Despite my fears that defragmenting would result in lost data and a drive that no longer booted (a fear from the early days of Mac OS X when I watched defraggers break symlink after symlink, destroying the operating system)

A simple defragmentation should not break symlinks. Defragmentation does not change a file’s location in the directory, only where it resides on the disk. Since symlinks are simply files which contain an absolute or relative directory path, defragmentation shouldn’t affect them. If a defragger was adversely affecting symlinks, then more had to be going on than simple defragging.

Now Apple’s aliases are a bit different than a symlink as they work off of FileID’s. If the defragger does more than merely move pieces of the file around (e.g. it creates a new file), then aliases will be broken.

Close Name:wraithe Posts: 7 Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Subject: Nothing like Norton? Thank God for that.

Ah'm sorry, let me stop laughing....Ok. There....

Norton NEVER worked well. O.K., that's a bit harsh. Norton hasn't worked well since at least 1990. The only thing that I ever relied on Norton's to do was find problems, and that only because it could be run on a live boot volume & Norton could fix very simple problems. I had a basic rule back in those days; I ran NDD, let it try and fix any minor problems - If it couldn't fix the problem at hand, or if there were more than 4 requests to fix errors, I would then abort and break out Central Point Disk Tools. This is WAY pre-Mac OS 9, and it never really got better, despite them buying out Central Point Disk Tools. I won;'t even start on how many times I've bailed out clients whose Tale Of Woe began - "So I was running Norton....and now it won't boot".

Nowadays, DiskWarrior is the crown jewel, IMO, I've been meaning to really try out Drive Genius, this review certainly makes me more willing to give it a serious looking at.

Close Name:wraithe Posts: 7 Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Subject: Defrgmenting...

[quote="Rainy Day"]As for Drive Genius, i have never used it, but much of it sounds superfluous. Such as defragmenting. Tiger automatically defragments most files.

Quote
Jeff Gamet wrote:
now even Apple recommends defragmenting your drive once a year.

Really? Where? I can’t imagine why, since Tiger already does this.

Well, to be fair, even you note that Tiger only de-fragments "most" files. I can de-fragmenting your drive as a yearly thing, esp. if you work with large-ish images/disk files/video. I certainly have a LOT of files over Panther/Tiger's 20MB "de-fragment threshold" on my my main home system.

However, I would also like to know where Jeff found Apple suggesting that you de-fragment once a year. It seemed reasonable until you pointed it out, and I went and looked and only found where Apple recommends that you _don't_ need to de-fragment: http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=25668

As far as trying out another tool, I agree that DiskWarrior is the king currently. But it never hurts to have more arrows in the quiver. Dare I say it - Even Norton has succeeded in rare cases where DW failed. Every dog has his day, after all.

Close Name:Jeff Gamet -   TMO Staff Posts: 102 Joined: 15 Mar 2006
Subject: Re: Just ain’t so

Quote

Quote
Jeff Gamet wrote:
now even Apple recommends defragmenting your drive once a year.

Really? Where? I can’t imagine why, since Tiger already does this.


It looks like Apple has done a bit of discrete backpedalling. KB article 303602 , originally titled "Top 10 Tips to Keep Your Mac in Top Form," used to clearly state that you should optimize your hard drive once a year. That was tip number 9. Most likely that was quietly removed on December 15, 2006. Here is what step 9 said:

-----
9) Optimize Your Hard Drive
To ensure the best system performance and keep file damage to an all-time low, optimize your hard drive once a year. Third-party utilities such as Alsoft Disk Warrior Optimizer and Micromat Tech Tool Pro will defragment and optimize your drive.

Be sure to back up important files before optimizing your drive.
-----

Steps 8 and 10 are missing, too. It seems Apple has decided that we no longer need to defrag our drives, and that there are only 7 tips we need to concern ourselves with.

I still haven't defragmented any drive that I use in my regular workflow. Like many other Mac users, I have been relying on Mac OS X's built-in defragging feature.

Jeff

Close Name:Guest
Subject: Terry

DiskWarrior is not a defragger. I think I'll buy Drive Genius based on this review even though I think it is overpriced.

Comment on this Article


You cannot edit your comments.   You cannot delete your comments.

Comments are currently closed. Please email the author instead.


Recent Headlines - Updated July 6th

Mon, 11:17 AM
Ted Landau's User Friendly View - Apple’s LED Cinema Display: A Too Short Story
11:11 AM
Product News - Photo Recovery for Mac Adds Photoshop Support
10:39 AM
Hot Forum Topic - iPhones in Education
8:47 AM
News - Apple Employee Injured in Store Shooting
Fri, 10:29 AM
News - Apple Warns of Learning Interchange Security Breach
7:30 AM
News - Happy Fourth of July!
Thu, 6:07 PM
TMO Scoop - Psystar Moves to Drop Bankruptcy Ahead of Apple Legal Battle
5:37 PM
News - Uncomfirmed Reports Say Apple & Nvidia On The Outs
4:57 PM
News - Microsoft Sick Over Barf Ad
4:09 PM
Product News - KRK Ships R6 Passive Studio Monitor for Recording
3:45 PM
John Martellaro's Blog - Particle Debris (week ending 7/2)  Juiced, Joost and Goosed
3:12 PM
Product News - ExactScan 2 Pro Released

The Mac Observer Reader Specials

  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!