The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Bookpedia 3.4

Review - Bookpedia 3.4

by , 9:00 AM EST, February 1st, 2007

Tracking the books in your library, whether for pleasure or work, is much easier when you have an application that can help you do that efficiently and easily. That's exactly what Bookpedia from Bruji does.

Bookpedia works almost exactly like its sibling application, DVDpedia, but instead of tracking your movie collection, this app tracks your book collection. Like DVDpedia, Bookpedia lets you enter books manually or you can use your iSight camera to scan barcodes. The most difficult part of using the application for me was getting the knack of exactly where to hold a book so that my iSight could scan it properly.


Bookpedia

The interface is similar to iTunes, so it feels familiar even before you get started. Much like iTunes, you can view your book library in a list view, or graphically by book cover. Both are useful - I found that I used the list view when reviewing my full library, and cover view when looking at smaller groups of books.

Selecting a book displays its information. You can enter that data yourself, or let Bookpedia fill it in for you when you first add the book to your library. The app has a long list of Web sites it can check for information including publisher and release date, author, cover art, synopsis, value, and more. If you have additional information you want to add, there are custom fields you can use as you like.

I tested Bookpedia's ability to accurately autofill an entry for me by scanning mass market printings of George Orwell's Animal Farm, and William Golding's Lord of the Flies. Both were added accurately to the database, although the book cover art for Animal Farm was wrong. That was most likely because my copy has new cover art, and not a problem with Bookpedia - Mass market book covers can change quickly. Scanning Bagombo Snuffbox by Kurt Vonnegut, Jr. worked perfectly, and the edition was even properly tagged as a reissue.


The book detail and edit window.

Manually entering a book name worked surprisingly well. I entered Lord of the Rings to see how Bookpedia would handle that, and it came back with a long list of possible matches. I was able to select entries from the list to see additional information, and then ultimately pick the correct edition for my database. I was expecting a short list of current printings, but instead got a long list with current and out of print options, which was really nice since I was looking for a version that had been out of print for some time.


Data entry searches return comprehensive lists of options.

The problem I found with entering a keyword, like a popular book title, is that you may get way too many responses. For my Lord of the Rings search, I ended up with 910 choices. An option to filter out things I'm not looking for, like audio books and paperback editions, would help to make searches go faster.

If you already have a catalog of your books in another application, like Delicious Library, Bookpedia can import the data for you. To my surprise, importing from Delicious Library also included the various book groups I had created.

Exporting data is easy, too. You can choose to export for use in another Bookpedia library, as a backup, HTML, for use with your .Mac account, to your iPod, and also as a text file. The cool thing about exporting to text is that you can also select BibTeX and EndNote templates for bibliographies.


You can export book info for bibliographies.

Just like DVDpedia, Bookpedia can also show statistics about your library. I found that I have a wide range of authors in my book collection, and that the majority of my books had cover prices between US$20 and $30. Who knew?

Statistics for authors, however, wasn't always accurate because minor variations in an author's name caused each version to appear as its own statistic. For example, J.R.R. Tolkien and J. R. R. Tolkien tracked as unique authors.

If you lend books out, Bookpedia can track who has what, and when everything is due. If someone fails to return a book on time, the app can email a friendly reminder for you. If friendly isn't your style, you can edit the reminder to say whatever you want.

The Bottom Line
Managing your book collection with Bookpedia is easy to do. Set up is painless, and if your data is already in another application like Delicious Library, there won't be any data re-entry, either. With the extensive list of online databases Bookpedia can reference when adding new books, you are also less likely to have to manually enter information. This app is a great option for personal libraries, work, and students.

Digg!


Product: Bookpedia 3.4

Company: Bruji

List Price: $18

4 out of 5 stars

Pros: iTunes-like interface, emails for over due books, bibliography export.
Cons: iSight scanning takes some practice.

Observer Comments

Show: Subjects Only | Full Comments
Close Name:jpfreeman Posts: 48 Joined: 12 Jan 2005
Subject:

I've been using Delicious Library. I'm glad to know that transferring my data would be easy, but how does the application compare to DL? Interface? Features? Does it find more books? I find that in DL some of my more obscure (foreign) books can't be found based on a scan. More turn up if I enter ISBN's manually. And then a lot of my books don't have cover images. iSight scanning took some practice with DL as well. Is scanning easier in one as opposed to the other?

Close Name:Pashtun Wally Posts: 145 Joined: 18 Dec 2001
Subject: Asterisk-Pedia vs Delicious Library - let's rumble!!!

I too use DL, and am fairly familiar with its shortcomings; I'm interested in the 'Pedia stuff, but specifically regarding how it compares AS A SET to the DL functionality.

I'd also like to know if there's a package price or crossgrade option for the DL crowd.

Close Name:Guest
Subject:

These days, one of the annoying things about reading reviews of book cataloging applications is that, all the while you're reading the review, you just *know* that people are going to start immediately referencing Delicious Library. In my opinion, DL is one of the most overrated apps of recent years, and it doesn't deserve the extra attention it's showered with to the detriment of the many other worthy products in the field (Booxter, Bookpedia, LibraryThing, and Books, just to name four off the top of my head -- but there are others).

Close Name:Guest
Subject: free alternative online.....

http://www.librarything.com/addbooks.php

a good runner up!

martijn
www.martijnaslander.nl

Close Name:gslusher Posts: 2088 Joined: 13 Nov 2002
Subject: DL vs 'pedias

Quote
jpfreeman wrote:
I've been using Delicious Library. I'm glad to know that transferring my data would be easy, but how does the application compare to DL? Interface? Features? Does it find more books? I find that in DL some of my more obscure (foreign) books can't be found based on a scan. More turn up if I enter ISBN's manually. And then a lot of my books don't have cover images. iSight scanning took some practice with DL as well. Is scanning easier in one as opposed to the other?


A lot of those problems are not built into the software but come from the varied and inconsistent databases Delicious Library and Bookpedia use to get information.

For more on Delicious Library vs the 'pedias, check this TMO review and scroll down to my comments and those following. I'd rather not have to repeat myself.

Comment on this Article


You cannot edit your comments.   You cannot delete your comments.

Comments are currently closed. Please email the author instead.


Recent Headlines - Updated February 9th

Tue, 9:00 AM
Hidden Dimensions - The Killer Surprises Waiting for Steve Ballmer
8:50 AM
Product News - Aperture 3 Adds Faces Support, More [Updated]
8:30 AM
TMO Quick Tip - Fixing iPhone and MobileMe Sync Headaches
8:12 AM
News - Apple Store Offline, Rumors Point to New Laptops
8:00 AM
TMO Appearances - TMO’s Bryan Chaffin and the Atomic Love Bombs Perform During Macworld Expo
Mon, 5:37 PM
News - Juniper Readies Software to Improve Cell Carrier Networks
5:17 PM
Macworld Expo - Macworld Expo 2010 Hess Party List Goes Online
4:11 PM
News - Survey: iPad Announcement Increased Awareness, Fails to Convert New Buyers
3:30 PM
TMO Appearances - Dave Hamilton Keeps Your Mac Lean and Clean at Macworld Expo
1:10 PM
TMO Appearances - Mac Geek Gab Live Recording at Macworld Expo
12:39 PM
Deal Brothers - Western Digital 750GB My Passport Essential SE Portable Hard Drive:  $129
11:46 AM
Product News - nova media Intros FoneSync for LG Handsets

The Mac Observer Reader Specials

  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!