The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Solomon Smith Barney Says Apple Will Hit Q2, Q3 Will Be A "Challenge"

Solomon Smith Barney Says Apple Will Hit Q2, Q3 Will Be A "Challenge"

by , 2:00 PM EDT, April 17th, 2001

Richard Gardner, an analyst with Solomon Smith Barney, and a long-time analyst following Apple in particular, has issued an earnings preview for Apple. Mr. Gardner says that the company will meet estimates for the current quarter, but that the June quarter, Apple's fiscal third quarter, will be a hard one for the company. "We believe Apple will report earnings in line with the current consensus of $0.03 (versus our estimate of $0.06)---the company may even deliver a penny or two of upside," says Mr. Gardner. "Unfortunately, we believe a solid March quarter will be followed by a more challenging June quarter."

Apple will be announcing their March quarter results in a conference call tomorrow at 2:00 PM, PST.

Mr. Gardner thinks weak consumer demand and US retail sales that have been particularly weak for Apple have had a major impact on the company. He cites PC Data figures which say Apple saw a 36% sequential decline in Apple's retail sales and a 49% drop in year over year retail sales. On the other hand, iMac sales for the quarter are actually up 14% over the December quarter's miserable results, though they are still 49% lower than 2000's March quarter.

Adding to Apple's woes, Mr. Gardner thinks that the company's pro market will actually be hurt by the strong offerings from Apple in late 1999 and early 2000, and that this will "keep most pro buyers on the sidelines." To read between the lines, Mr. Gardner is suggesting that Apple's current professional PowerMac G4 models are not compelling enough to convince many professional buyers to upgrade. Mac OS X will also impact Apple's Q3 results. "Pros may defer upgrades pending availability of systems pre- loaded with Mac OS X and the porting of their key applications to the platform," says Mr. Gardner.

Titanium PowerBook sales helped Apple in the March quarter, but, says Mr. Gardner, "the PowerBook alone will likely not allow Apple to achieve current consensus estimates for the June quarter. While we are optimistic about demand for the new PowerBook Titanium and Mac OS X upgrades, we believe the contribution from these two items will be overshadowed by weakness in other product categories and/or is already fairly reflected in our estimates."

The report concludes by saying Apple will be trading in a narrow range and suggests that investors take profits should there be any positive movement after Wednesday's announcement from Apple. According to Mr. Gardner, "While Apple shares seem inexpensive, we believe current revenue and earnings estimates will prove aggressive and would use any significant rise in the shares following Wednesday's announcement as an opportunity to take gains."

Solomon Smith Barney maintains a Neutral, High Risk Rating for Apple and a target stock price of US$24.

For other stories regarding Apple's stock activity, visit our updated Apple Stock Watch Special Report. You can also check out our Apple Financial Boards, where we have a thread on this topic.

The Mac Observer Spin:

Mr. Gardner is one of the few analysts on Wall Street who seems to actually understand Apple. This report reflects the company's Neutral, High Risk rating on Apple, though it may seem somewhat pessimistic to some Apple investors. The biggest issue we see is whether or not Apple lowers guidance for the June quarter in their conference call tomorrow. Mr. Gardner seems most pessimistic about that quarter, in large part because of the build up towards MACWORLD New York when Apple has announced they will begin shipping new Mac models with Mac OS X pre-loaded.

We also find it interesting that Mr. Gardner recognizes, or at least seems to recognize, that Apple is hurt by the longevity of their own products. On the one hand, many people use Macs because of their longevity. On the other hand, that means that Apple has a much longer upgrade cycle than its Wintel counterparts where 2 years is considered a lifetime for PCs. We also note that Mr. Gardner did not make a stronger statement about the inability of Motorola to keep up with Intel/AMD in the MHz wars and the impact that has had on Apple's sales.

Recent Headlines - Updated March 27th

Fri,12:56 PM
TMO Daily Observations 2015-03-27: Tim Cook is the Top Leader, Leshi TV says Apple is Hitler
10:56 AM
Leshi TV CEO Says Apple is Hitler
9:29 AM
Apple Watch Compatible Apps are Already Arriving
8:55 AM
Numbers: Using the Quick Calculations Bar
Thu,9:20 PM
7 Things We Learned when Fortune Named Tim Cook World’s Greatest Leader
8:22 PM
How To Sell, Trade In, or Recycle Old Macs or PCs
7:35 PM
Apple’s App Store, iTunes, iBooks, Software Update Briefly Down for Some Users
6:08 PM
The New MacBook Giveaway
1:21 PM
TMO Daily Observations 2015-03-26: Apple’s Revamped iTunes Radio Plans, Amazon’s Big Cloud Storage
12:20 PM
X-Doria Defense Shield Case for iPhone 6 - Beautiful Yet Passes Drop Tests
11:31 AM
Amazon Adds Unlimited Storage Options to Cloud Drive
10:32 AM
Apple Tasks Jimmy Iovine, Trent Reznor with Making a Spotify Competitor
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!