The Mac Observer

Ted Landau's User Friendly View

Ted Landau's User Friendly View

...Long live the iPods

TMO Talk (3)
Apple today unveiled its latest round of updates to its iPod lineup. In case you are trying to sort through the announcements, in an effort to decide which iPod(s) to buy for the upcoming holiday season, here are my instant recommendations:

The iPod touch. The iPod touch is the one to get if you can afford the extra $100 bucks (over a nano) and are not bothered by its larger size. By adding volume controls and an external speaker, the iPod touch finally achieves major feature parity with the iPhone. The touch can now be honestly described as a phoneless (okay, and cameraless) iPhone. For some people (including myself), the iPhone itself remains the more attractive choice -- if only because it combines two devices (a mobile phone and an iPod touch) into one. But the iPhone is also much more expensive (when you consider the cost of the required two-year contract) and locks you into AT&T (here in the U.S.). For those who find all that untenable (of which there are many), the iPod touch is a spectacular alternative. Get one!

The iPod nano. This is still a keeper. The nano just keeps getting better. More significantly, at $100 less than a comparable iPod touch, it remains the smallest least-expensive "full" iPod that you can buy. The nano is the one that will continue to fill the most Christmas stockings this season. For me, the nano's biggest improvement is the combination of its new shape plus accelerometer. By allowing you to shift from a vertical to a widescreen view, the nano becomes a more pleasing device for watching video.

The iPod shuffle. I would not recommend anyone buy an iPod shuffle -- unless price is the overriding consideration. If the cost of an iPod nano is out of your reach, and you are determined to have some sort of iPod, go ahead and plunk down $49 for a shuffle. But be aware that you are getting a screenless iPod that has almost none of the features that make its siblings a success. I am not sure how profitable the shuffle is for Apple. But I strongly suspect that as soon as Apple can find its way to pricing an iPod nano below $100, it will dump the shuffle entirely.

The iPod classic. I would not recommend anyone buy an iPod classic -- unless you truly need its 120GB of storage. Why? Because for $20 less(!) than the cost of a classic, you can get an 8GB iPod touch. For just $50 more than a classic, you can get a 16GB iPod touch. If either of those sizes are sufficient (and based on the success of previous generations of iPod nanos, most iPod users find these sizes more than sufficient), you are much better off buying a touch. The iPod touch is an even better iPod than a classic and -- as a bonus -- offers several dozen non-iPod features (including Wi-Fi capability and access to App Store apps). Some people may claim that they prefer the classic, regardless of storage considerations, because they neither want nor need the non-iPod features of the touch. Or that they prefer the click-wheel interface to a touchscreen. Okay. So Apple can keep the classic around for those few holdouts. But, as with the shuffle, expect Apple to shunt the classic to a virtual corner somewhere. It is telling that Apple's press releases from today don't even mention the upgraded shuffle or classic.

I can imagine a not-too-distant future where the iPod shuffle and iPod classic no longer exist. A scaled back iPod nano may remain for those who still want its simplicity, small size and low cost. But the vast majority of Apple's sales will be going to the touch and the iPhone. At that point, Apple's refrain could be: "The (old) iPods are dead; long live the (new) iPods."

P.S. As for the iPhone 2.1 software and iTunes 8.0, also announced today, I'll be covering them in future articles.

In addition to his role here at The Mac Observer, Ted Landau is a Senior Contributor for Macworld, the author of several Mac and iPhone help books, and the founder of MacFixIt. You can .(JavaScript must be enabled to view this email address)  Ted Landau or post your polite comments below.

Post A Comment or Log-in. Need an account? Register here.

3 Observer Comments

   Actions Dan said on September 9th, 2008 at 4:15 PM (Edited: 11/25/2008 4:05 PM):

I will likely be buying an iPod classic because, on a Mac, it can act as a portable boot-drive.  This means I can leave my portable hard-drive at home and just carry my iPod when traveling, which I would do anyway to avoid draining my iPhone (in case I want to actually use it as a phone on the other end of my trip)!

Otherwise, I agree with your assessments.
——-

   Actions Don said on September 9th, 2008 at 5:00 PM (Edited: 11/25/2008 4:05 PM):

I don’t think you appreciate the charm of the iPod shuffle—it’s so light and small that you don’t realize you’re wearing it. Those characteristics plus its extreme ruggedness make it an ideal companion for even vigorous activities.

   Actions bound4centralasia said on September 9th, 2008 at 5:14 PM (Edited: 11/25/2008 4:05 PM):

While I understand the arguement, and maybe for most people there good enough. I for one want something that works as a home stereo. I could hook up my computer, but why? I just need a music Server. I could use a apple TV but why and I need more than 80gb. So when it comes down to it I am happy with the classic especially with the price drop, or the memory increase of to 120. Now I might run out and see if I can find a 160 for 249 because I would be a fool not to buy the 160 if I could get it for the same price. My guess they never sold that many and found most wanted 120 which is what I want but I could always find a use for the extra 40, though I doubt any of it would be video.
Just my thoughts on my pocket book.

Post A Comment or Log-in. Need an account? Register here.
 

Recent Headlines - Updated May 25th

Thu, 7:56 PM
News - Jonathan Ive Tells BBC He Wants to Stay at Apple
7:44 PM
News - Apple’s European Head Departs
6:01 PM
News - Apple Pulls Rogue Amoeba’s Airfoil Speakers Touch from App Store
5:33 PM
Product News - Apple Updates Aperture for External Editors, Snow Leopard
5:23 PM
Mac Geek Gab Premium Podcast - MGG 399: Five Questions from Three Scotts
5:16 PM
News - Apple & Others Settle Mobile Lawsuit With Patent Firm SimpleAir
4:44 PM
Editorial - How the Ripples in Apple’s TechSphere Will Influence Us
4:02 PM
News - Microsoft Wins Motorola Android Device Ban in Germany
3:14 PM
News - Jury: Google’s Android Doesn’t Infringe on Oracle’s Java Patents
2:41 PM
Quick Look Review - Casellet: iPhone 4S Case and Wallet Combined
1:12 PM
Deal Brothers - 13” MacBook Air 1.86 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo:  $1,099
11:18 AM
News - Sharp Teams with Foxconn for iPhone Display Production
 

The Mac Observer Reader Specials

  • Macsales Add 2nd Hard Drive or SSD to Mac mini, MacBook or MacBook Pro. 1TB of Hard Drive or SSD Capacity from $64.99! Video Guides Make it easy - OWC DataDoubler - Macsales.com
  • Mac RAM Upgrades: MacBook Pro 16GB kits $475, 8GB Kits for $119.99! iMac 16GB RAM Kits (4x 4GB) for $229.99! Mac Pro Memory 32GB Kit for $399.99, 64GB Kit for $889.99! Mac Hard Drives 2TB Seagate SATA II for $249.99! Click Here!
  • Macpokeronline.com If you're using a Mac, then you've gotta check out PokerOnAMac.com. Online casinos and poker rooms are literally giving away cash and the casino sites at Poker on a Mac do the unthinkable, they actually reward! Join today, the download is free!
  •  Looking to find online casinos for mac? We can help you find the best real money casino sites where you can play your favorite casino games including blackjack and slots.

Apple Stock Quote (AAPL)

Loading...

Hot Topics

TMO Express

Join the TMO Express Daily Newsletter to get the latest Mac headlines in your e-mail every weekday. Find out more!

Top Deals From DealBrothers.com

Recent Features

Support The Mac Observer

We noticed you may be running AdBlock on your computer. It takes real money to run this site and to deliver the news, tips, and opinions you love to read.

If you wish to block the ads that pay for the creation of our content, we ask that you instead support TMO Directly, either with a $5 monthly recurring contribution, or a one-time donation of any amount of your choice. Thanks!

Subscribe with Paypal Donate with Paypal