The long and short of the iPhone’s battery

| Ted Landau's User Friendly View
Guess what? The more you use your iPhone, the faster its battery drains. This is hardly a surprise.

Further, certain iPhone features require a bit of extra power and will drain the phone's battery even faster. Again, not much of a surprise. It's simply a matter of physics.

Still, it's worth pointing out exactly what these battery-eating features are. It may be of particular interest to iPhone 3G owners, many of whom claim that the 3G's battery life is significantly shorter than that of the original iPhone.

In its iPhone User Guide, Apple offers several tips as to what to turn off in order to conserve battery life:


    On page 86, Apple states: "To conserve battery life, turn Locations Services off when you’re not using it."

    On page 102, Apple states: "You might want to turn Push off...to conserve battery life."

    Later on the same page, Apple adds: "When Push is off or for accounts that do not support push, data can still be “fetched." For optimal battery life, don’t fetch too frequently."

    On page 104, Apple further notes: "Using 3G...may decrease battery life. If you’re making a lot of phone calls, you may want to turn 3G off to extend battery life."


On its "Batteries - iPhone" page, Apple offers additional battery-saving tips. These include: (a) Turn off Wi-Fi; (b) Turn off Bluetooth; (c) Use Airplane Mode in low- or no-coverage areas; and (d) Minimize use of third-party applications (especially games that prevent the screen from dimming or shutting off or applications that use location services).

Apple also suggests turning off the display for video podcasts, and just listening to the audio. It similarly follows that watching any extended video (such as a movie) should be avoided if you need to preserve your iPhone's battery for other higher priority tasks.

Of course, all of this can be taken to impractical extremes. I can imagine a satiric skit about the iPhone battery, with the punch line advising that the best way to maximize the life of your iPhone's battery is to turn off the iPhone altogether and never use it.

Battery life and the iPhone 3G

But seriously folks, what about the iPhone 3G? Does it really eat up a battery faster than an original iPhone? I've read several articles on this subject and have done some informal testing on my own. My (still a bit tentative) conclusion is that, when settings between an original iPhone and a 3G are the same, they use up the battery at about the same rate. The biggest reason that 3G users may see increased battery drain is due, not to the hardware, but to the new 2.0 software: Location services, push, downloaded games and the like. However, as these items are available to original iPhone owners as well, they shorten battery life on any iPhone (or iPod touch!). It is only the 3G service itself that may lead to a faster decline in battery life on an iPhone 3G. And while keeping 3G enabled does appear to take a toll, I have not found it to be a dramatic difference. In any case, the iPhone 3G is competitive with other 3G smartphones (as shown in this chart from PCWorld).

The 3G's mystery battery drain

There is one irritating exception to the above generalizations. There is a battery drain that occasionally happens with my 3G but never with my original iPhone or iPod touch. It is quite dramatic and, unfortunately, I still don't know the cause.

Perhaps once a week or so, the life drains out of my iPhone 3G's battery at an alarming rate, even when the iPhone is sleeping! For example, my iPhone may still have about 80% power left at the end of the day. As such, I may decide not to connect it to a charger. The next morning, I turn it on and find the red "low battery" warning on the screen, claiming I now have less than 10% battery power left. My original iPhone and iPod touch, on the other hand, show almost no battery decline during this same period. I have seen numerous similar reports but still have not found a solid explanation.

My current theory is that the iPhone is activated by some process while sleeping, such as the arrival of a text message or a phone call or a pushed email. For some reason (presumably due to a bug that affects the 3G but not original iPhones), the 3G doesn't correctly go back to sleep after this. Instead, it stays in some quasi-active state and begins to drain the battery as if I were actually using the phone. The next morning, when I finally wake it up, the battery charge is almost gone.

I have experimented to see if some particular iPhone feature (such as having push or 3G enabled) is the primary trigger for this symptom. Apparently not. I still have these occasional battery drains, whether these features are on or off. Hopefully, an iPhone firmware update will eventually resolve this problem. [Meanwhile, if you believe you know what is going on here, please email me to let me know!]

What else to do...

Assuming your use of the iPhone demands that most or all of its battery-draining features remain enabled -- and that your iPhone is losing its charge more quickly than you would like, what can you do?

• Charge your iPhone's battery every night. At least you'll always start the day with a full charge.

Apple also notes: "It’s important...to go through at least one charge cycle per month (charging the battery to 100% and then completely running it down)." Otherwise, the length of time that a charge lasts will decrease.

• Keep an extra charger in your car and/or at your office -- so you can charge your iPhone "on the go." Just be aware that "the iPhone 3G cannot be charged with a FireWire power adapter or FireWire-based car charger."

• If you charge your iPhone by connecting it to your Mac, make sure your Mac does not go to sleep while charging. Apple warns: "If your iPhone is connected to a computer that’s turned off or is in sleep or standby mode, the iPhone battery may drain."

• Consider getting an external battery for your iPhone, such as the Kensington Battery Pack and Charger. Such devices can be especially useful when you won't have access to a power source for an extended time, such as when on an airplane. You can watch a movie on your phone and still have a separate full charge left for the remainder of the day.

Finally, you can hope that Apple one day releases an iPhone with a replaceable battery. That way, you could carry around a spare battery and swap it when needed. This is what I routinely do with my digital camera. It would be great to have the same capability for the iPhone. But I'm not holding my breath here. Apple hasn't yet offered a replaceable battery for any iPod or iPhone. I'm not expecting them to change their policy any time soon. But I can still hope.

Sign Up for the Newsletter

Join the TMO Express Daily Newsletter to get the latest Mac headlines in your e-mail every weekday.

Comments

James

I’ve actually had the battery drain on my 8GB V1 iphone running the 2.0 software after receiving a text message, but never turning my phone on to see it.  Just last night I checked my phone, and had 80% battery life.  Later in the evening I received a text message from a friend.  I never checked my phone and went to bed.  In the morning I checked my phone and was surprised to see a red battery and icon stating that I should connect my phone to a charger.  I don’t think this is unique to the 3G phones, but rather an issue with the iphone 2.0 update.
——-

steve schmetz

there doesn’t seem to be a charger for the 3g iphone. the kensington units are not compatible with the 3g per kensington

Art

I have to agree with James.  There are times when my 8GB V1 iPhone with 2.0 software is not actively used, but the battery drains out within a few hours.  I can tell when this is occurring, the iPhone is much warmer than usual, just as if I was using the phone on a long call, or using the web for an extended time. 

When I feel the phone getting this warm, I first try holding the home button for several seconds to stop any runaway process, if that fails, I turn the phone completely off, wait 30 seconds and restart.  That usually stops the rapid drain.

Ted Landau
[quote comment=“2396”]I have to agree with James..

Well, it’s certainly possible that it is not unique to the 3G. I haven’t had the problem except on my iPhone 3G, but that could be a lucky coincidence or from the fact that I use the 3G for more things than my other devices.

I too have noticed the business about the iPhone being warmer to the touch when the symptom occurs.

Snaab4
[quote comment=“2395”]there doesn’t seem to be a charger for the 3g iphone. the kensington units are not compatible with the 3g per kensington

Check this out (I just ordered two):
http://www.richardsolo.com/index.asp?PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=264

Frank

I think sleep is not not what everyone thinks - in “sleep”, it still has to listen for phone calls, emails, SMS, alarms, etc. I believe the OS and programs are still running. I think all that sleep is is simply blanking the display and turning off the touch screen.

Allan

It would be nice if there were a switch like the “Airplane Mode” switch to turn off 3G, location services and other battery-gobbling functions. I get good battery life out of mine when I turn off all this stuff, but it would make my life easier if I could to it in one fell swoop.

jimothy
[quote comment=“2395”]there doesn’t seem to be a charger for the 3g iphone. the kensington units are not compatible with the 3g per kensington

After a great experience with Griffin tech support (and a dismal one with Kensington], I purchased the PowerJolt. Their web site doesn’t yet state it as 3G compatible, but their friendly tech support confirmed that it does. I picked up one at Target, and I can also confirm that it works with the 3G.

http://www.griffintechnology.com/products/powerjoltiphone

Any USB-based charger, for home or the car, presumably will work.

Robert1014

Maybe I’m a weirdo, but I turn my iPhone off at night…I wouldn’t think of leaving it on in sleep mode while I’m asleep myself. For one thing, if I’m near a land line, either at my apartment or at my office, I use those, and others call me on my land lines. For another thing, I wouldn’t expect to be getting messages at night, and if I do, I’ll see them in the morning when I turn the phone on.

I do keep all the extraneous services turned off unless I specifically need them; yes, it would be nice to have a “one touch” command to turn them on or off, but it takes not time to turn on or off the specific services I might need, it’s really no inconvenience at all. With my usage, as well as these habits I’m developing, I don’t have to charge my iPhone 3G more than about every two days.

Constable Odo

After-market companies are you listening?  How about supplying an internal longer life battery for the iPhone.  OWC offers longer life batteries for the MacBook Pro.  If a third-party company can design a more efficient battery and maybe one that uses up the maximum amount of space (I saw the inside of the iPhone 3G and it doesn’t look like there’s any spare room) even if it comes at a premium price.  Please do something to give the iPhone a longer time between charges.

DocRoss

I, too, have had the rapid drain on my 1st Gen 8GB phone. It happened just 2 days ago. I wondered if it had something to do with Pandora. I had run Pandora over EDGE for a few minutes to see if I could (I could!!), and then shut it off. Not long after, I noticed that the phone was warm to the touch, and by early afternoon, I was out of juice altogether—necessitating connecting to iTunes to re-activate!

I’m not sure if it’s Pandora, but it’s happened to me just once—after using Pandora.

Cheers.

steve schmetz

The Power Jolt is the only charger(for car) that apple’s store website says is ok for the iphone 3G. The two by kensington do not have apple’s approval and may not work now or after software updates up to know.

vjvejogvaln

smC1up qitrfvricoai, nevytjtaceih, [link=http://lunjqjrfgegf.com/]lunjqjrfgegf[/link], http://naaimvwqbgqn.com/

Log-in to comment