Apple Sued Over Digital Camera Patent
December 7th, 2009 at 11:57 AM - News by Brad Cook
Apple has been sued by St. Clair Intellectual Property Consultants over the digital camera used in the iPhone. St. Clair claims Apple is infringing on four of its patents and wants damages and a jury trial. The court documents, which were filed in Delaware, where Apple is incorporated, can be found online.
The company has a successful track record of defending those patents, according to The Loop: it sued Sony in 2001 and scored a US$25 million judgment, and in 2003 it sued Canon and won $34 million. It has also gone after many more companies – including Fuji, Kyocera, Minolta, Nikon, Samsung, HP, RIM, Palm, and others – and secured licensing agreements for its technology.
The law firm Morgan Lewis calls St. Clair a “patent troll" in a PDF presentation on its web site. The PDF notes: “St. Clair purchased patents from a group of inventors who failed to establish a camera company. The purchase price was less than $100K. St. Clair hired its lawyers on a contingency base [sic] and pays them about 35% of the money it receives.”
9 Observer Comments
But what do the patents actually cover? Neither the ‘online’ link nor the ‘according to the loop’ link actually say what the patents are for.
I saw that too but it sounded to me like he was being facetious.
.
Parasites! Pure and simple. When will this stuff end? Either patents are woefully easy to get or the courts are awfully liberal. How many times in the past six months have we seen Apple taken to court for similar infractions? Maybe Apple needs to do better research. I don’t know what.
The patent granting system is a joke. Too often patents are granted to obvious ideas and methods (please reference the patent granted for swinging on a swing sideways).
Considering the filing dates on some of the patents, there may be a “prior art” argument that they’re invalid, at least in part. The “899” patent was filed in 2000, but there were already digital cameras on the market by that time.
Recent Headlines - Updated March 21st
- Fri, 5:55 PM
- Games - Namco Releases Match-Three Game Tinseltown Dreams to the App Store
- 5:16 PM
- News - iPad Launch Day Deadline for Developers: March 27
- 5:11 PM
- News - Steve Jobs Helps Promote Organ Donor Legislation
- 4:06 PM
- iPad - VIVmag Shows Off Interactive iPad Version in the Works
- 3:07 PM
- App Store - Microsoft Yanks Bing App From Foreign App Stores
- 2:05 PM
- iObserver - Analysts Downgrade Troubled Palm Amid Severe Revenue Drop
- 1:35 PM
- In-Depth Review - PhoneSuite MiLi Packs a Powerful Punch
- 1:11 PM
- News - YouTube to Viacom: Sue Yourself
- 11:34 AM
- Product News - PocketMac for BlackBerry 5 Improves Snow Leopard Support
- 10:59 AM
- News - Apple iGroups Patent Hints at Social Networking Plans
- 10:20 AM
- Hot Forum Topic - Reader Discussion: Who Will Buy Palm?
- 9:50 AM
- News - Bharti Airtel Lands India iPhone 3GS Deal
The Mac Observer Reader Specials
- TypeStyler For Mac OS X is Now Shipping! Download The Free Fully Functional 60 Day Tryout at www.typestyler.com
Mac Memory and Hard Drives: MacBook Pro Memory 8GB kits $349.99! iMac Memory 4GB DDR Kits for $109.99! Mac Pro Memory 4GB Kits for $135.99! Mac Hard Drives 1.5TB Seagate SATA II for $147.99! Click Here!
- CarMD Handheld Device & Mac/PC Software System saves you time and money on car maintenance and repair. Buy at www.CarMD.com! Save $10 with code TMO2.
If you're using a Mac, then you've gotta check out Full Tilt Poker for Mac. This Full Tilt Poker bonus code does the unthinkable, it actually rewards!For the latest Apple products use Ciao, a price comparison website, to find laptops like MacBook Air. Then find the best prices on MP3 players and use our comparison tool to evaluate mobile phones like the Apple iPhone.

2nd Gen. Refurbished 32GB iPod touch: $249.00 Delivered
Refurbished MacBook Air 1.6GHz Intel Core 2 Duo $1099.00 Delivered
