Microsoft Video Offers Hamfisted Attack on Google Apps

| Analysis

Microsoft has published a video called Googlighting to YouTube—that’s Google’s YouTube—that attempts to make the case that Google Apps are little more than a side project for the search giant, a flaky and unreliable side project at that. Google Apps are Google’s attempt at free, cloud-based productivity apps that directly compete with Microsoft’s cash cow, Office.

The video is a companion to Microsoft’s Why Microsoft? website that contrasts Microsoft’s offerings to Google’s for businesses. It runs in the same vein as other comparisons Microsoft has made in the past to Apple’s Macintosh (PC vs. Mac), Linux, and others through the years.

We suspect the video is supposed to be funny, though there’s little evidence to back up our hypothesis. Google Apps is presented as a smarmy, young sales guy who’s not to be trusted. We know that because he has a silly tie, a crappy suit, and two days growth on his face. Who can trust a punk kid who doesn’t shave as often as he should?!?

Googlighting Screenshot

Who could trust this guy?!? He’s got one of the wrist thingies!

The reality is that it’s a hamfisted attempt that comes off looking more pathetic than amusing. Those more charitable might forgive it as something that a bunch of aging, out-of-touch execs in Redmond thought was simply high-larious and let it go at that. Maybe it was the same team who thought that having Ryan Seacrest co-host Steve Ballmer’s CES keynote would somehow improve that event.

Then again, maybe that’s the point. By definition, the target market for the video are business execs at companies contemplating free Google Apps as a replacement or to augment the not-at-all free Microsoft Office. It could well be that said target audience will find the video just as high-larious as did whomever it was that gave the go-ahead to push this baby out to YouTube in the first place.

A quick perusal of the comments on YouTube will shockingly find that Microsoft isn’t winning any converts on the site, but as noted above, YouTube denizens aren’t the target market for this video.

In any event, here’s the video. Maybe you can find a more positive perspective on it than we did.

Microsoft’s “Googlighting” Video

Sign Up for the Newsletter

Join the TMO Express Daily Newsletter to get the latest Mac headlines in your e-mail every weekday.

Comments

Lee Dronick

I am certainly not a business exec, but I liked the ad and it will probably will appeal to the targeted demographic. The Googlelighter comes off as smarmy and untrustworthy, the interviewer is intelligent and astute.

I like the Google colors in his necktie, nice touch.

mblaydoe

@Lee Dronick, unlike the Microsoft vid, your post was truly funny.

Lee Dronick

@Lee Dronick, unlike the Microsoft vid, your post was truly funny.

I should put on my white suit and offer MicroSoft my services.

furbies

Ok. The ad is complete excrement but M$ does raise valid issues.

My deity, did I just agree with M$ ?

Kill me, kill me now!

Bosco (Brad Hutchings)

I thought Bryan would have a funny “ham fist” graphic for this post. I am disappoint.

Bryan Chaffin

Drats! I should have, Brad. That’s a lost opportunity, but maybe another opportunity will present itself. smile

Garion

“Don’t trust the Googlighting stranger,
‘cause he’s not on your side”

Subtle, Microsoft - very subtle.

*facepalm*

wab95

I agree with Lee, this will affect a select demographic quite effectively, awkward moniker notwithstanding. This was MS doing a surgical strike.

All it has to do is inject a single drop of FUD into the psyches of these older, less tech-savvy but busy decision-makers and most will not stray from the ranch.

This is the basic formula of scary ‘fairy tales’, and they have worked quite well for centuries.

Log-in to comment