Retina MacBook Pro Mountain Lion Battery Life: 10.8 vs 10.8.1

| Analysis

UPDATE: MacBook Air battery tests are now available.

On Thursday we ran some battery life tests to determine the impact that OS X 10.8 Mountain Lion had on the battery life of portable Macs. Using a 2011 15-inch MacBook Pro, we confirmed that 10.8 results in a serious degradation of usable battery life — in our case over 30 percent — and that the 10.8.1 update restored only about half of the lost battery life compared to the running time we could achieve on the same hardware in OS X Lion 10.7.4.

We’re continuing to investigate the impact of the Mountain Lion battery life issue and we now have results from a new 2012 MacBook Pro with Retina Display (rMBP). Our 2011 MacBook Pro was a Mac that had been used for over a year and had a battery that, while still healthy, had quite a few cycles on it. In contrast, our rMBP is brand new and, aside from a battery calibration before starting the tests, has hardly been used.

Retina MacBook Pro Mountain Lion Battery Life

The rMBP is an upgraded base model, with the 2.7 GHz i7 CPU, 16 GB RAM, and a 256 GB Apple SSD. To recap from Thursday, our tests were performed by using a custom Automator application under battery-saving conditions: the screen at 50 percent brightness, keyboard illumination off, and all applications and services disabled except for WiFi. To keep the Mac running throughout the test, we disabled system and display sleep in System Preferences, and deactivated the screen saver.

Our Automator app performs the following actions:

  1. Open TextEdit, pause 10 seconds.
  2. Open Safari and navigate to a content-heavy website (macobserver.com), pause 20 seconds.
  3. Navigate to a second content-heavy website (cnn.com), pause 20 seconds.
  4. Open Mail, pause 10 seconds to allow any messages to download
  5. Close all open applications
  6. Log a time stamp to a text file
  7. Repeat

We initially saw some unexpected results — as we’ll explain later — so each test was run multiple times, and the results below are averaged. We’ve placed the results from the 2011 MBP in the chart as well, for the sake of comparison.

Of note, although the first rMPBs shipped with 10.7.4, it was a unique build of Lion specific to that machine. Our rMBP shipped with 10.8, and we did not have access to the special 10.7.4 build to run a comparison test. Therefore, our rMBP analysis is primarily focused on the difference in battery life between 10.8 and 10.8.1.

Mountain Lion 10.8 Retina MacBook Pro Battery LifeChart by The Mac Observer

The rMBP scored better than our 2011 MBP, but that was to be expected considering the more power-efficient components and architecture found on the newest member of Apple’s laptop family. What was surprising was that 10.8.1 brought no improvement in battery life on rMBP. In fact, as averaged on both 10.8.1 tests, the update resulted in slightly decreased running time compared to 10.8.

Retina MacBook Pro Apple Battery Life

Apple advertises “up to 7 hours of wireless web” battery life for the rMBP, and our 6h 53m result on 10.8 is close enough to declare that the rMBP is operating normally. Even the slightly lower 6h 40m average for 10.8.1 is a good score compared to Apple’s advertised numbers.

In light of our test results, it appears that the battery life issues associated with Mountain Lion are generally limited to traditional MacBooks. While we would have liked to have been able test 10.7.4 on the rMBP, Apple’s battery life estimates for the rMBP lead us to believe that there is no significant battery life issue for the rMBP on Mountain Lion. Customers interested in moving to a Retina Display Mac should therefore not be too concerned about degraded battery life.

We are continuing to test other MacBook models, and we’ll have results from a 2011 13-inch MacBook Air on 10.7.4, 10.8, and 10.8.1 on Saturday.

Teaser graphic via Shutterstock.

Sign Up for the Newsletter

Join the TMO Express Daily Newsletter to get the latest Mac headlines in your e-mail every weekday.

Comments

anovelli

I guess I must be some kind of heavy user, since I have never ever seen much more than 3 hours between charges on my 2011, even when new. I know I usually have at least 4-10 applications running, often with a few to several documents open in each, as many as 10-15 Safari windows open, with as many as 10 tabs in some of them, screen brightness maxed, keyboard backlight on auto, mail always open, etc. Usually have graphics switching on. If I quit everything and run Red Crucible on a full charge at full screen, I don’t even get an hour.

Always makes me suspect of these claims. Always makes me want to have my head examined smile

Robin Bollen

There is a nice UNIX low level command that shows what is happening on disk level, it pumps lots of output but in many occasions it has helped me understand OSX better and it’s installed 3rd party apps (ctrl-c stops the output).

The command is fs_usage
It needs root permissions, so you might run “su -” before.

Once I had a NTFS tool installed and it was doing crazy disk access all the time. So I removed that one.

When people ask me to take a look at their machine, it is the first thing I do. I just ran the command again and iPhoto does a lot of activity but I don’t have the application open.

16:07:30.362349 select             S=1                                                                               0.000071 W iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.362368 select             S=1                                                                               0.000003   iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.362391 select             S=1                                                                               0.000018 W iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.362425 select             S=1                                                                               0.000023 W iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.362457 select             S=1                                                                               0.000004   iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.362489 select             S=1                                                                               0.000026 W iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.367580 select             S=0                                                                               0.005081 W iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.367754 select             S=1                                                                               0.000005   iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.367804 select             S=1                                                                               0.000003   iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.418656 select             S=0                                                                               0.050845 W iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.418885 select             S=1                                                                               0.000006   iPhoto.65712
16:07:30.418936 select             S=1                                                                               0.000003   iPhoto.65712

So I kill the app because I am not using it and I don’t even want it to do thing behind my back.


ML:~ root# ps -ax | grep -i photo
2720 ??      15:29.03 /Applications/iPhoto.app/Contents/MacOS/iPhoto -psn_0_757945

ML:~ root#
ML:~ root#
ML:~ root# kill 2720


PS the output is truncated

Log-in to comment