The Mac Observer

Samsung Loses Patent Complaint; Apple Complies With Italian Court Ruling

TMO Talk (11)

Apple’s ongoing legal matters continued on Friday with a pair of events: a German court struck down Samsung’s second patent complaint against Apple, and Apple has placed a “Communication to protect consumers” notice on its online Italian store in compliance with a court ruling that said the company was pushing AppleCare while neglecting to tell buyers about the two-year warranty that’s legally mandatory in Italy. Apple was fined 1.2 million euros as part of the court ruling in Italy.

Florian Mueller, who runs the blog FOSS Patents, attended the German court ruling against Samsung. He wrote: “Judge Andreas Voss did not state any particular reasons for the decision … Different reasons are conceivable. The outcome of Samsung’s first two German actions against Apple may be based on reasons specific to the validity and/or infringement of those patents, in which case Samsung could still prevail over any or all of three other 3G/UMTS patents it is asserting against Apple in Mannheim. Samsung is furthermore suing Apple over two non-standards-related patents, including a patent on a method to enter smileys on a mobile device.”

He went on to say that he expects Samsung and Apple to continue with their respective lawsuits against each other. “Since both companies are doing very well (with Apple being not just highly but even unbelievably profitable), they can afford to keep going, and at this point neither litigant has the leverage to force its rival into a settlement,” he said.

In the online Italian Apple store, the “Comunicazione a tutela dei consumatori” link opens a PDF that explains the two-year warranty legally mandated in that country. The Register received a confirmation from Apple that it is still appealing the initial ruling against it, so the company hasn’t yet paid the 1.2 million euro fine levied against it.

The notice that now appears at the online Apple Store in Italy

Register reporter Bill Ray observed: “When the ruling was published we said it seemed unlikely Apple would be unaware of local laws, and given that retail operation Comet managed to modify its similar practices to avoid a fine we were surprised to hear that Apple was being hit so hard.”

Post A Comment or Log-in. Need an account? Register here.

2 Observer Comments

Great analysis from Florian - thanks for posting his comments, Brad.

Looks like Samsung got “Samsunged” once again - too bad!!

smile

The more interesting patent victory this last week came about in the Federal District Court for the Northern District of Illinois. The ITC handed Apple a narrow victory against HTC regarding Apple’s 263 patent, but the scope of the victory made it easy for HTC to work around the patent. Apple appealed to the District Court. The District Court has widen the scope of the patent. If this sticks, it will be bad news not only for HTC, but Motorola, Samsung and the rest as it will allow Apple to argue willfully patent infringement against Google. Foss has a write up on this as well.

Post A Comment or Log-in. Need an account? Register here.
 

Recent Headlines - Updated May 27th

Sat, 10:00 AM
MacOS KenDensed - MacOS KenDensed: Apple’s Patent Lawsuit & Antitrust Shuffle
Fri, 5:58 PM
News - Sotheby’s to Auction Steve Jobs Atari Memo (Photo Gallery)
5:42 PM
Free on iTunes - 3 Free iOS Apps for News Hounds
3:00 PM
Rumor - Nest Thermostat Reportedly Coming to Apple Retail Stores
2:40 PM
Particle Debris - The TV Industry’s Dreadful Little Secret
2:33 PM
News - Mobile Devices Account for 20% of Web Traffic in US, Canada
12:49 PM
News - Apple Now Offering “Free App of the Week” for iOS
12:21 PM
News - Tim Cook Declines $75 Million Dividend Payout
11:25 AM
News - Absinthe 2.0 Provides Untethered Jailbreak for iOS 5.1.1
11:09 AM
Quick Look Review - F18 Carrier Landing (iOS) is a Boatload of Fun
10:51 AM
TMO Appearances - Jeff Gamet talks Cool Apps & Accessories on Not Another Mac Podcast
10:12 AM
Hot Forum Topic - Forum Poll: Which is Your Favorite Photo Sharing Service?
 

The Mac Observer Reader Specials

  • Macsales.com for the Right Mac Memory. Most Popular: 16GB from $128; 8GB from $50. MacBook Pro & Mac mini Kits up to 16GB. iMac up to 32GB & Mac Pro now up to 128GB. - Macsales.com
  • Mac RAM Upgrades: MacBook Pro 16GB kits $475, 8GB Kits for $119.99! iMac 16GB RAM Kits (4x 4GB) for $229.99! Mac Pro Memory 32GB Kit for $399.99, 64GB Kit for $889.99! Mac Hard Drives 2TB Seagate SATA II for $249.99! Click Here!
  • Macpokeronline.com If you're using a Mac, then you've gotta check out PokerOnAMac.com. Online casinos and poker rooms are literally giving away cash and the casino sites at Poker on a Mac do the unthinkable, they actually reward! Join today, the download is free!
  •  Looking to find online casinos for mac? We can help you find the best real money casino sites where you can play your favorite casino games including blackjack and slots.

Apple Stock Quote (AAPL)

Loading...

Hot Topics

TMO Express

Join the TMO Express Daily Newsletter to get the latest Mac headlines in your e-mail every weekday. Find out more!

Top Deals From DealBrothers.com

Recent Features

Support The Mac Observer

We noticed you may be running AdBlock on your computer. It takes real money to run this site and to deliver the news, tips, and opinions you love to read.

If you wish to block the ads that pay for the creation of our content, we ask that you instead support TMO Directly, either with a $5 monthly recurring contribution, or a one-time donation of any amount of your choice. Thanks!

Subscribe with Paypal Donate with Paypal