GUH!!
I just downloaded this thing, and have been playing around with a sample piece of music: “Toss the Feathers” by The Corrs. It’s a good piece of sample music to deal with: Celtic fiddle, electric guitar, faint sounds of the band in the silent parts, and a wide range of drums for a pretty significant range.
I’m SERIOUSLY impressed!
I encoded this at 56kbps stereo using Quicktime. It encoded at roughly the same rate as an MP3 file. The quality was nearly indistinguishable from the original uncompressed AIFF. There was none of the characteristic “warble” that low-bitrate VBR encoding gives in MP3, and the file size was naturally equal to that of a 56K MP3. The nly area where it really fell down at that bit rate was with the soft snare-drum in the introduction, which was somewhat muted and softened. To a casual listener, especially over MP3 radio, this wouldn’t be noticeable. I only nopticed it because I was directly comparing it to the original AIFF.
I’ve also been playing around with some of my old Animations. One of the thorns in my side when producing my website have been a number of old animations done at school. Everything is light greys on white, with a fair bit of noise. So far, the only format that has given me any sort of quality has been MPEG-1, which really lacks any cheap solution for the Mac. Quicktime codecs, even Sorenson 3, have all chocked badly on these, requiring either very large file sizes, or terrible quality.
I just finished playing around with my old “Dancing Badgers” Animations. I’ll upload these tomorrow night for comparison, of anyone is interested. In a nutshell, the MPEG-1 displays noticable artifacting, has tinny, poor-quality audio, and is 542 KB for an 11 second animation at 256X182. MPEG-4 shows negligable artifacts, has far better audio, runs at 320x240, and is only 472 KB!
To get these results yesterday, I would have had to shell out over $550 for Cleaner 5.0 on the Mac. Suddenly, having to shell out $30 to re-register Quicktime Pro looks rather reasonable.