Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover for iPad: Limited, Still Great

| In-Depth Review

The Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover (UKC) for the iPad fits over the face for travel and opens to create a stand and keyboard. The design is elegant, the keyboard is terrific, but there are just a few compromises and limitations. Overall, it's still a great product for the price.

It's a fact. There are some people who need a really good keyboard for their iPad when on the move. Even though Apple doesn't provide one and has opted to retain a vision of a pure tablet for its millions of customers, there are those who still desire a keyboard. When it closes up to protect the iPad and matches its style, so much the better.

For more on this philosophy, see the recent review of the Brydge.

The gist here is that we're interested in how well the product performs and what its features are -- without regard to thoughts about whether one should be even using a physical keyboard. It's a matter of need and taste, so let's get on with the review.

Design

The UKC is a flat keyboard assembly that has magnets on the edges. When the iPad (2,3 or 4) is brought into close contact, in preparation to cover the iPad, the rear magnets grab the iPad, and then the remaining magnets keep the duo securely closed up.

However, when the iPad is opened and still connected with the virtual hinge on the back, there is nothing to hold the iPad at any given angle. The iPad must be pulled away, and then placed in the special gutter. That constrains the iPad to stand at a fixed angle, 30 degrees from the vertical. Some users may find that annoying; I did.

Next to a 2011 13-inch MacBook AIr

You could insert the iPad in portrait mode, but it becomes a bit top heavy and seems to put some stress on the gutter. It's really designed, it seems, to be used in landscape mode. Neither Logitech's marketing images nor the manual suggests use in portrait mode.

When the iPad is in place, the gutter keeps it positioned fairly well. However, there is no positive, secure fit. Even though I was able to lift the duo by the iPad, and they stayed together, a slightly stronger jostle will separate them. As a result, I judge that the best use of the UKC is on a desk. If you do decide to sit with the assembly on your lap, I think it's possible that the iPad could topple out and fall to the floor if nudged strongly. In contrast, the Brydge can much more safely be used as if it were a MacBook on one's lap.

The UKC comes in a white or black face and keyboard to match either the white or black iPad. In either case, the back is a thin layer of aluminum that matches the color and texture of Apple's iPad. The plastic keeps the weight down, and the UKC weighs only about 11 ounces. However, the price paid is a certain amount of strength and durability compared to solid aluminum.

Aluminum back matches iPad.

Unlike the Brydge, which has a MacBook-like notch on the front edge of the keyboard to enable a convenient opening pry, there is, instead, a slender gutter in front of the spacebar. When closed securely by the magnets, it takes just a little bit of extra prying to get the iPad pulled open and away. This is an observation, not a complaint.

Like Apple's Smart Cover, the iPad will wake/sleep when the UKC is opened/closed.

Setting up the UKC

As with just about all keyboards of this type, the connection to the iPad is via Bluetooth. The UKC remains in discovery mode for 15 minutes after you turn it on. If necessary, there's also a Bluetooth connect button on the side next to the on/off switch. Then, as usual, you go to the iPad's Settings -> Bluetooth to pair them. The Bluetooth connection is for the keyboard only; there are no built-in speakers.

Logitech says that a full charged battery should last about six months if used for two hours a day. A strong plus for this product is that the battery is user replaceable. Unfortunately, Logitech provides a paper manual that describes the process but doesn't state what kind of battery to use. So you'll find out when you pry the unit open with a screwdriver. (I tried to pry it open, but didn't have the right size screwdriver and just succeeded in scratching the case.)

Out of the box, I was immediately put off by how short the micro USB cable is. I was hard pressed to reach the USB hub on my desk that sits right under my iMac's display. It's 16 inches (40 cm.) long, and that sounds adequate, but it really isn't when you need to place the iPad and UKC in a convenient postion on your desk during charging.

Using the UKC

The first thing one notices is how good the keyboard looks and how good it feels. The spacing between key centers is 16 mm, the same as the Brydge, but the keys action is just slightly softer. Personally, I like that because keys with a soft action allow me to type faster for some reason. (I'm typing this, however, on an Apple aluminum keyboard for publication.) I judge the key action/feel to be excellent, almost as good as any dedicated keyboard you might buy.

There is no LED for the caps lock.

The next thing I noticed, to my great joy as I wrote notes to myself, is that the Delete key is protected. That is, you must first press the Function key to lock the iPad's display. There are no worries there, and that's great foresight and thoughtfulness. The Home key, which will kill an app, is also thoughtfully placed out of the way on the far left above the Tab key.

The keys are gorgeous, crisp but soft feel

At first glance, I had a hard time finding the back-tick and tilde keys. On this keyboard, they're more or less hidden away over the bracket/braces keys and must be accessed with the Function prefix key. Once you know where these seldom used keys are, it's not a problem.

Overall, this handsome product is a joy to look at and use. One must be aware of its limitations, however. The fixed tilt angle and the susceptibility to accidental separation from the iPad are serious considerations.

Due to the design and placement of the gutter, there is no wrist rest at all. But then, considering that it's best used on a desk anyway, that may not matter.

Packaging and Documentation

The UKC comes in a very thin box but with a cardboard tray and plastic to protect it during shipping. Included is a cleaning cloth, a booklet with warranty and safety information, a 10 page user manual, and the micro USB cable.

The manual is complete and well written, except for battery information. However, I was endlessly amused by the fact that the manual itself (on page 1) shows a picture of the manual and has a call out that explains that it (the picture of the manual) is the manual. Logitech has a wry sense of humor.

Custom laser engraving is available. Just enter the text when checking out on the Logitech website.

The Verdict

The Logitech Ultrathin Keyboard Cover is a handsome, well-priced product and has a keyboard any novelist could live with. It's well laid out and just gorgeous. The soft feel may or may not appeal to users, but if you like the Apple aluminum keyboards, you'll like this one.

While it's mostly plastic, it doesn't have a cheap plastic feel. The fit and finish are excellent, and it matches the look of the iPad perfectly. I do, however, worry that one will scratch the case prying it open with a screwdriver to replace the battery. A compartment latch/detent would have been a nice touch.

For some, the way the iPad sits in the gutter may not be a secure as necessary for some conditions, and the fixed 30 degree tilt from the vertical may not be acceptable. Also, the opportunity for stereo speakers was bypassed, presumably to keep the cost down. However, if this doesn't affect you, and your principal consideration is low weight and the Logitech brand and reputation, then it's a winner.

For those who want to compare this against the Brydge, recently reviewed, here's a comparison chart.

 

  Brydge Logitech UKC
Speakers Stereo None
Secure fit Yes No
Caps Lock light No No
Micro USB cable
length
40 in
(1 m.)
16 in
(40 cm.)
Weight 1.4 lbs
(590 g)
0.72 lb
(329 g)
Total thickness
w/ iPad 3
17.5 mm 16.5 mm
User replaceable
battery
No Yes
Material Solid
Aluminum
Aluminum
backed plastic
Sleep/Wake Yes Yes
Prot. DEL key No Yes
Tilt Angle Infinite 0-180 deg

Fixed (30 deg

from vertical)

 

Product: Ultrathin Keyboard Cover for iPad (2,3,4)

Company: Logitech

List Price: US$99.99

Pros:

 Light weight, very good keyboard, protected Lock key, ingenious use of magnets, instant on/off, black or white colors, aluminum back, paper manual, very good looking.

Cons:

Not a completely secure fit with iPad, fixed tilt angle, no speakers, no wrist rest, micro USB cable too short.

Sign Up for the Newsletter

Join the TMO Express Daily Newsletter to get the latest Mac headlines in your e-mail every weekday.

Comments

khaled

there is white and red(apple e-store) versions

Richard

I’ve been using the LUK for several months and have been very happy with it. The cable is too short—another 4-6 inches would be great. I dropped the keyboard and iPad not too long ago, and both now have matching dents on one corner, but both still perform fine. I like how the style of the keyboard matches the iPad—a nice touch. I also have the Tablet Keyboard for the iPad, and I actually prefer that one if I am going to do more extensive typing (it’s a bit bigger, and offers two viewing angles). The LUK, however, is a perfect combination of cover, keyboard, and portability. Re: the angle limitations—move your legs to adjust it if you’re using it in your lap. You could probably use the exercise! wink

Da

What do you mean by a protected delete key? I have this kb and just hit the delete key as needed. When I press function and delete key, it serves as the sleep key/function.

John Martellaro

Da: That’s exactly how it’s supposed to work. That is, you have to press the function key first.

Da

Thanks for confirming. Thought you meant you had to hot fn and delete to delete. Thanks!

Scott S.

I bought the LUK (labeled “For iPad-2 and 3rd Generation”) last night and couldn’t get it to sync with iPad-Retina (4th Generation).  It worked fine with my iPad-3, and the Retina worked fine with an older Dexim bluetooth keyboard.  Is the Bluetooth chipset different in iP-4?

John Martellaro

Scott:  I asked my Logitech rep about this.  She’s checking.

Da

Someone in my office is using one with their brand new 4th gen Ipad.  It should work.

John Martellaro

Scott:  My Logitech replied and said that the iPad 4 should be compatible. They affirm this in a blog entry.

http://blog.logitech.com/2012/11/01/got-a-new-tablet-logitech-has-you-covered/

If you’re still having problems, I’ll get you connected with Logitech.

Log-in to comment