The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Think Secret Gets Pro Bono Legal Help in Apple Lawsuit

Think Secret Gets Pro Bono Legal Help in Apple Lawsuit

by , 5:10 AM EST, January 20th, 2005

A lawyer specializing in freedom of speech and the Internet said Wednesday he will defend free of charge ThinkSecret.com owner Nicholas Ciarelli, who is facing a lawsuit over an article that revealed trade secrets about the Apple Computer Mac mini, the Web site has reported.

The 19-year-old web publisher and Harvard University student will be defended by Terry Gross, of the San Francisco-based firm Gross & Belsky. Mr. Gross said in an interview that Ciarelli and his Web site used proper newsgathering techniques.

"Think Secret's reporting is protected by the First Amendment," Mr. Gross said. "The Supreme Court has said that a journalist cannot be held liable for publishing information that the journalist obtained lawfully. Think Secret has not used any improper newsgathering techniques."

Mr. Gross said he plans to file a motion asking a judge to immediately dismiss the lawsuit.

Apple sued Ciarelli a week after his Web site published an article that revealed details of the US$499 Mac mini. Apple then announced the supposed new CPU on Jan. 11.

Another Think Secret story on Jan. 6 correctly predicted Apple's announcement last week of the $149, 1 gigabyte iPod shuffle digital media device.

Apple's lawsuit alledges ThinkSecret.com "solicited information about unreleased Apple products" and is seeking monetary damages and information about sources used in the story.

Recent TMO Headlines - Updated May 23rd

Tue, 10:22 AM
IKEA is Making HomeKit Smart Lights Affordable for Everyone
Tue, 9:14 AM
Apple and Nokia Reach Agreement in Patent Licensing Dispute
Mon, 6:41 PM
Supreme Court Just Killed Marshall Texas Patent Troll Business
Mon, 6:00 PM
Apple Plans to Change Scrolling in Safari
Mon, 5:27 PM
The Good That Has Come Out of Apple's Mac Lapses
Mon, 5:14 PM
Apple's New Switcher Campaign — for iPhone
Mon, 4:00 PM
Time-Lapse Video of Living Zen Sand Art Coffee Table
Mon, 3:46 PM
TMO Background Mode Interview with Computer Historian and Author David Greelish
Mon, 3:34 PM
Leaked Pics Compare iPhone 8 Size to iPhone 7s and 7s Plus
Mon, 2:03 PM
Apple's Driverless Test Car Caught in the Wild
Mon, 1:50 PM
Ford's Interest in Autonomous Cars, iOS 11 Wish List - TMO Daily Observations 2017-05-22
Mon, 1:35 PM
114 Year Old Car Company Puts Self Driving Car Exec In Charge
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!