The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Detroit Free Press: iWork Needs Some Work

Detroit Free Press: iWork Needs Some Work

by , 7:10 AM EST, January 25th, 2005

Mike Wendland, a columnist for the Detroit Free Press who often writes positive pieces about Apple and the Mac platform, said Tuesday he thinks Apple's new software package, iWork, needs some work. Mr. Wendland wrote that Pages isn't a full-featured word processing program, and that Keynote "seems a bit klutzy" compared to Microsoft's PowerPoint."

iWork was introduced by Apple during Macworld San Francisco earlier in January. The software is comprised of Pages, a word processing application, and Keynote 2, the successor to the formerly stand-alone Keynote presentation solution that Steve Jobs uses to put on his own keynote presentations.

Calling Pages the more interesting of the two applications, Mr. Wendland wrote, "It's really a tool for creating newsletters, stationery, brochures and the like more than a word processor. Oh, you can write letters and documents and even save them to the Word format, but for anyone who does a lot of writing, this is not the main word processor you'd want to use."

In a somewhat harsh assessment, Mr. Wendland said "At best, Pages is a poor man's version of the Microsoft Publisher program for Windows."

As for Keynote 2, Mr. Wendland noted that it is easier to work with and "greatly improved" over its predecessor, "it still seems a bit klutzy compared with PowerPoint. For instance, it lacks PowerPoint's ease of imbedding and playing movies in slides."

Comparisons to Microsoft's established Word and PowerPoint are inevitable in that Pages and Keynote are both intended to serve the core functionality of their Big Redmond counterparts. Though the iWork suite is a fraction of the price of just Word, for instance, many consumers and professionals alike will be making the comparison, whether or not either of Apple's offerings are intended to replace Word or PowerPoint.

Mr. Wendland's review attempts to look at the applications from that view point. You can find the full review at the Free Press's Web site.

Recent TMO Headlines - Updated June 22nd

Thu, 6:50 AM
Apple Wants to Pay Record Labels a Smaller Share of Apple Music Revenue
Thu, 5:55 AM
Reader Demographics, Third-Party Ads Now Available to Apple News Publishers
Wed, 4:47 PM
Apple Rolls Out iOS 11, watchOS 4, tvOS 11, and macOS High Sierra Developer Beta 2
Wed, 3:37 PM
Dr. Mac Interviews John Sculley
Wed, 3:14 PM
Virgin Mobile Wants You All-In With the iPhone
Wed, 3:01 PM
A Bold Move for Apple: MacBook Air 2 for Education
Wed, 2:09 PM
Blue Microphones Ella Planar Magnetic Headphones Hands-on Review
Wed, 1:16 PM
Scott Forstall's Computer History Museum Fireside Chat - TMO Daily Observations 2017-06-21
Wed, 11:45 AM
JOBY GorillaPod & GripTight Smartphone Mounts: $14.99
Wed, 10:44 AM
Apple Opens Registration for Apple Camp and Today at Apple Kids Hour
Wed, 10:40 AM
2016's Game of the Year 'Hitman' Now Available for macOS
Wed, 10:19 AM
Well This is Awkward: Uber Tips Coming to a City Near You
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!