The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Creative Plans Music Player Patent Battle

Creative Plans Music Player Patent Battle

by , 12:25 PM EST, December 8th, 2005

Sim Wong Hoo, CEO of Creative, a maker of digital music players, told the BBC that he plans on aggressively pursuing protection for a patent the company owns. The patent describes a way of using menus to navigate through songs on a digital music player.

Mr. Sim commented "We will pursue all manufacturers that use the same navigation system. This is something we will pursue aggressively."

Although Creative isn't naming who it plans on going after, odds are Apple is at the top of its list, with the release of the Vision:M digital and video music player may be a shot across Apple's bow. The Vision:M bears an uncanny resemblance to Apple's video capable iPod, and its menu setup seems to go beyond a coincidental similarity. It even goes so far as to include a green battery indicator in the upper right corner of the display, just like iPods with color screens.

The Vision:M's resemblance to the video capable iPod is nothing more than coincidence, according to Mr. Sim. He denied that his company copied Apple's design, saying Creative's product had been in the works for more than a year.

Creative may have come on scene earlier with a digital music player, but it's Apple that controls the market. Creative has been playing catch-up ever since the iPod started selling.

If Creative were to win a court battle over its patent infringement claims, that could spell trouble for other digital music player companies, including Apple. A settlement could include anything from royalty payments to Creative, up to injunctions barring the sale of competing MP3 players.

Recent TMO Headlines - Updated September 20th

Thu, 5:25 PM
Big Cable Asks For More Money, Refuses to Discuss Internet Speeds
Thu, 5:11 PM
Inside Look at NSO Group iPhone Malware
Thu, 5:00 PM
Activity Trackers Now Mandatory for John Hancock Insurance
Thu, 4:50 PM
Become a Maker with 12 eBooks on 3D Printing, CNC Routing, and More: $19.99
Thu, 2:31 PM
Here's the Best Apple Watch Series 4 Size Comparison
Thu, 2:09 PM
Current Products Give Hints About Apple's Future
Thu, 1:55 PM
DNC Wants Democrats to use iPhones and Ditch Android
Thu, 1:40 PM
Apple Won't Say Why It Blocked AdGuard and Freedom
Thu, 1:32 PM
Apple Watch for Android Phones, Notifications Tips - TMO Daily Observations 2018-09-20
Thu, 11:52 AM
watchOS 5: How to Enable Raise to Speak for Siri on Apple Watch
Thu, 10:50 AM
Apple Working to Bring Apple Watch Series 4 ECG to Canada
Thu, 10:10 AM
Amazon Unveiling New Hardware at Surprise Event Today
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!