The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
New Apple iMac Earns C|Net Editors' Choice Award

New Apple iMac Earns C|Net Editors' Choice Award

by , 1:45 PM EDT, August 9th, 2007

C|Net gave the new Apple iMac it's Editors' Choice Award on Wednesday. The iMac was cited for its best-in-class design, solid feeling, thin but solid keyboard, iLife '08, and performance in multimedia benchmarks.

C|Net noted that, regarding the internal hardware, the changes have been simply generational, with new CPU speeds and graphics card updates. Except for extreme gaming, the iMac holds its own. "Now that the Intel-compatible Mac version of Photoshop CS3 is out, Apple can compete on a level playing field with Windows desktops," Rich Brown wrote for C|Net.

"And as expected, the new iMac dominates on Photoshop and on multimedia multitasking, and it also does very well on iTunes and CineBench, the latter as much a measure of overall multicore processing power as it is an indicator of a system's ability to process movie files. Compared to a wide range of competing mainstream desktops, the new Apple iMac more than holds its own, with one typical exception: gaming."

Fourth Generation iMac

C|Net noted that Apple's implementation of 802.11n was a deciding factor in the Editors' Choice Award: "If you spec out a system from any other PC vendor, you'll get within $100 or so of a comparable iMac, but of all the major computer vendors, only Apple offers Draft N wireless in a desktop."

In addition, the keyboard was well received, and the reviewer noted a smooth response that made it a pleasure to type on.

Mr. Brown also had a few complaints. Apple was criticized for not making its upgrade plans more clear regarding Leopard and even went so far as to suggest waiting until October to buy one of the new iMacs when Leopard will be free. Apple's 90 days of phone support was also criticized, and "always feels like a slap in the face when we read it." However, it was pointed out that, as compensation, the Apple community is so strong that it can often make up for that deficiency.

Overall, the iMac received a score of 8.2 out of 10, which is an excellent score for a C|Net review. The final conclusion was notable. "Unless you're a gamer or an upgrade enthusiast, we can think of very few reasons not to make an iMac your next desktop."


Recent TMO Headlines - Updated February 21st

Thu, 2:59 PM
When Algorithms Fail, Apple's Credit Card – TMO Daily Observations 2019-02-21
Thu, 2:41 PM
London Could Remain Europe's VC Capital After Brexit
Thu, 2:22 PM
Former Apple Lawyer Bailed on $500k Bond
Thu, 2:22 PM
American Companies Help China With DNA Collection
Thu, 1:57 PM
Not Satisfied With 5G, Trump Wants 6G Cellular
Thu, 1:52 PM
Amazon Future Engineer to Offer Computer Science Education for Thousands of Underprivileged Students
Thu, 1:50 PM
What Apple, Others Want for Data Privacy Rules
Thu, 12:43 PM
How This New York Times Reporter Uses Apple Notes for Her Job
Thu, 12:07 PM
Apple Car Might Actually be an Electric Van Instead
Thu, 11:01 AM
Pedophile Ring Uncovered on YouTube
Thu, 10:50 AM
Israel Launching First Mission to the Moon
Thu, 10:47 AM
Save on Fandango Tickets for the Oscars With Apple Pay
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!