The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Apple Sued Over iChat Video Background Feature

Apple Sued Over iChat Video Background Feature

by , 11:10 AM EST, November 16th, 2007

Apple was hit with yet another patent infringement lawsuit this week. First, there was the suit over predictive typing, and now its the custom video backdrop feature in Leopard's iChat.

California-based Digital Background Corporation filed its case against Apple on November 14 in the Illinois Southern Federal District Court. The 1997 patent describes a process where the background in an incoming video signal is repaced by an alternate background in real time -- just like iChat can do.

While on the surface the patent and its description seem fairly clear cut, everything surrounding it is a bit murky.

The patent inventor, Michael Steffano of Austin, Texas, filed for the patent in 1997 after he founded Viewics Corporation -- a company he sold in 2001. The patent was actually assigned to The Metaphor Group in Irving, Texas, on June 9, 1998.

According to Patent Troll, Mr. Steffano recorded in 2004 that the patent had been assigned to Digital Property Management Group (DPMG) on March 18, 1997. Digital Property Group, however, wasn't actually formed until 2001. DPMG's sole member was Bruce Renourd, vice president of sales for Power Integrations -- a company that coincidentally Apple has done business with.

Canada's patent filing (available as a PDF) doesn't match the US filing, or Mr. Steffano's claims, and shows that the patent belonged to Viewics Corp.

So far, there doesn't appear to be any documentation linking this patent to Digital Background Corporation.

When a trail gets this convoluted, there is usually a surprise twist, and in this case, it's the parent company for Digital Background Corporation: Acacia Research, the same company that is suing Apple under the Autotext Technologies name over the predictive typing patent. Acacia Research doesn't actually create any products; Instead, it develops, acquires, and licenses patented technologies.

The company is asking for a permanent injunction to stop Apple from selling copies of Leopard that include the iChat backdrop feature, triple damages, and attorney fees. AppleInsider reports that the suit also asks for an order forcing Apple to recall Mac OS X 10.5 from wholesalers, destroy equipment that already has Leopard installed, and send letters to everyone that holds a copy of Leopard stating the "sale or solicited commercial transaction was wrongful."

Sticking with company policy, Apple has not commented on the case.

Recent TMO Headlines - Updated July 2nd

Fri, 5:13 PM
TikTok Claims Strong Data Security, Still Planning to Improve It Further
Fri, 4:35 PM
Apple to Cut iPhone 14 Orders By 10% Despite High Demand, Sources Indicate
Fri, 4:12 PM
Celebrating the Anniversary of the iPhone: Looking at the Time Apple was Exclusive to AT&T
Fri, 3:16 PM
Steve Jobs to Posthumously Receive the Presidential Medal of Freedom
Fri, 2:43 PM
Former Apple Securities Lawyer Pleads Guilty to Six Counts of Insider Trading
Fri, 2:27 PM
Apple Has Interviewees Think Outside of the Box, Other Tips for Landing a Job with the Company
Fri, 2:21 PM
Apple Suppliers Are Already Working on Second-Generation OLED iPad
Fri, 2:11 PM
Apple Promotes the Apple Watch Series 7 as A Durable Device in the New 'Hard Knocks' Video Ad
Fri, 1:34 PM
My Penultimate Column
Thu, 4:12 PM
Apple TV+ Unveils Trailer for New Family Comedy 'Best Foot Forward' Premiering in July
Thu, 3:34 PM
Apple's Issue With In-House 5G Chip May Be a Legal, Not Technical Problem
Thu, 2:14 PM
Apple Planning to Launch M2-Powered MacBook Air July 15
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Daily Observations
  • TMO on Twitter!