Yes, iPad Pro CAN Replace A Computer

2 minute read
| Editorial

We have seen a lot of talk about how you can get a new iPad Pro but it certainly isn’t a “real” computer. Apparently it falls short in a number of ways, since it doesn’t do Everything A Mac Can Do. Well guess what? Not every user is actually doing Everything A Mac Can Do right now.

iPad Replacement Examples

Let’s start with someone who spends “computer” time looking at web pages, checking email, a bit of social media, and online banking. If that’s most of what they’re doing, an iPad is more than adequate.

E.T. with computer.

See? Even on other planets they just use iPads.

Now let’s look at someone who is producing online audio. Record using anything from Voice Memos (part of iOS) and the built-in mic, or one of many recording apps and a microphone. Then you can edit with apps like Ferrite. I know this to be true, because I have recorded and edited more than one podcast using only my iPad. I have asked more than one person if they could hear the difference and the only person who said they could tell which was which actually chose the recording from my laptop, not my iPad.

If you’re doing video production, you can shoot video up to 4K with the rear camera, and again there are loads of apps to choose from, two popular ones being iMovie from Apple and LumaFusion. Again, you can work with high quality files and publish online immediately. You can capture and produce a finished product and share it with others just as you could if you had a laptop with you.

My final example: Someone like me who spends a lot of time using web tools and assembling words and images into varying formats. Drop a keyboard (Smart or otherwise) in the mix and I can type as fast as I can on my “regular” setup. I have fully functioning iOS apps like Scrivener and/or responsive web pages for tools I use, and while the steps are a bit different, I can still do all the same things.

Not For Me Isn’t Necessarily Not For Anyone

Is this every possible example of user? Not even close. Does everything work exactly the same on iOS as it does on macOS? Obviously not. But that doesn’t negate the iPad as a viable option for a lot of people. I have talked about this for ages: If everyone had a moment of technological honesty, it’s entirely possible a whole lot of people would see that an iPad (not even the latest model) is a more than adequate upgrade. We’ve reached a point where “full” computers aren’t being revolutionized yearly, and the hardware is fast enough now the slowness usually isn’t in the machine anymore. Now it’s the Wi-Fi or the app having trouble, not your computer lacking horsepower.

11-inch and 12.9-inch iPad Pro with USB-C

Take a good long look at what may well be your new computer. You heard me.

I have personally seen more than one person “upgrade” from an old computer to a new iPad who couldn’t be happier. They are gaining speed and portability, and it works just like the iPhone, so they know their way around from the start. When your baseline is a much older computer whether it’s a Mac or a PC, this is a really nice upgrade for a good price.

Be skeptical of these reviews, because “it’s not for me” is vastly different from “it’s not for anyone.” This point of view has gotten more and more common among pundits, who dismiss something outside their perspective then go on to write about how this new thing clearly isn’t popular (and if we’re talking about Apple, why this means they’re obviously doomed).

9
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
3 Comment threads
6 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
6 Comment authors
Kelly Guimontwab95John KheitAndhaka Recent comment authors

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  Subscribe  
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
wab95
Member
wab95

Hello Kelly: First, congratulations on a very nicely articulated article. I’m pleased to see more articles along these lines that not simply point out the obvious, namely that iOS devices, iPad Pro included, are computers. It should be obvious by now that, in this century, computers come in a variety of forms and, by design, serve different use cases. Additionally, you point out two other general but relevant facts. First, what we do with our devices, and how we do those things, affect which devices will be useful to us. Second, that a device does or does not serve our… Read more »

Andhaka
Member
Andhaka

Is it now possible to have different apps as default apps? Like not having Safari as a default browser opening when clicking a link?

If not, still not a replacement for me.

Cheers

John Kheit
Member
John Kheit

I agree with this analysis, but I think it misses what is a bit of misdirection. The scope of work types that can be done by a computer are generally greater than an iPad. If you happen to only use what is provided for by the iPad. Then great, you’re golden. But if you need greater scope, then it’s not. So if all you ever do is open the back of computer tower cases, then a screw driver is all you need. But if you’re working on ferrari’s, youre going to need a tool kit with broader abilities. Apple marketing… Read more »

Member
shameermulji

“Apple marketing the iPad as a replacement for “what’s a computer” is it sticking it’s neck out as a universal replacement.” Even though Apple considers an iPad a computer nowhere do they suggest is it a universal replacement. At least, not what from I’ve seen. If anything, that “what’s a computer” views it as an alternative. Problem is, is that people keep confusing them for Macs. They’re not Macs. Using SJ’s car / truck analogy, cars did not replace trucks and last time I checked they still don’t but trucks are still sold for those that need to do that… Read more »

John Kheit
Member
John Kheit

I don’t confuse them. SJ also said there will always be a need for trucks. We disagree. The entire point of that commercial is showing that the student can do oh-so-much creation for school work as a replacement. It’s not true. Go to any teenager that has access to both an iPad and laptop and say you’ll take away their laptop because they don’t need it for school. See what happens. It won’t be pretty. And that’s my point, APPLE is advancing the narrative in posturing the iPad as a universal replacement with “what’s a computer”. It shows a girl… Read more »

Member
dennyhenke

John you start in your first comment in agreement with the article but by the end of your second post you seem to be repeating the same idea that actually the iPad is only good for consumption with the the addition of illustration with the pencil. If I read Kelly’s post correctly she’s suggesting that it’s actually capable of quite a lot more than that. Speaking in regards to what I do and what I’ve read of others doing with the iPad, I think your view is really off-base. The iPad has been my primary computer for 2+ years now… Read more »

John Kheit
Member
John Kheit

It’s capable of some more than mere consumption, but much less than a general purpose pc. And it’s closer to consumption only than full of production on that scale of things. Apple pitching it as a replacement is disingenuous.

Yes I can use a Moped to haul a few select groceries home or ferry a single kid to school, but positioning it as a replacement for a regular car is disingenuous.

Member
dennyhenke

Regarding teens, the one dynamic I have observed is this… many of today’s teens (at least in my family) grew up with iPads as their first computer. They associate iPads with being a kid. They observed middle-aged grown-ups using iPhones and laptops. The exception is seeing their grandparents using iPads. I think what’s happened is that they associate the iPad with being computers for kids and grandparents. Teens being teens in 2018 there’s a good chance they have an iPhone now and often get by with just that. But if they need a bigger computer than the phone they don’t… Read more »