The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
One Day, Apple Will Resume Its 'War' With Microsoft

One Day, Apple Will Resume Its 'War' With Microsoft

by , 8:00 AM EDT, October 12th, 2001

Proceed, Solinus, to procure my fall,
And by the doom of death end woes and all.

Shakespeare, The Comedy of Errors, Act I, Scene 1

Experience is the name everyone gives to their mistakes.

Oscar Wilde

Introduction: Don't go, Avie, don't go!

Scene: Steve Jobs' office…

Steve Jobs, Apple CEO, took the news as though the news bearer were speaking with the banality that one exhibits when reading a grocery list. In other words, he didn't lose his cool.

In front of his desk stood Dr. Avadis "Avie" Tevanian, Apple Vice President of Software Engineering. Dr. Tevanian has just tendered his resignation, effective December 31.

"Why would you want to do this, Avie?" Jobs asks, in genuine puzzlement.

"You know the deal we had, Steve," Tevanian replies, spreading his arms out in a gesture of helpless resignation. "Do I need to remind you? When we took over Apple in '97, I agreed I'd help architect the road to OS X. I threw in my lot with you to replace the Mac OS with NeXTSTEP. I've done it. I've fulfilled my end of the bargain. Now, fulfill yours: let me go, Steve. I miss the laboratory. I want to get back to take Mach to the next level."

Jobs, leans back in his chair, stares at the ceiling for few seconds then responds.

"Okay, Avie, so you want to quit." Jobs repeats what he's just heard. "But, I figured that you'd stay on, once you saw the potential in this Macintosh thing. The world needs us to stay the course. Look at the crap that the world will turn to by default." He aims his arm towards a laptop at a table in the corner, running a demo of Windows XP. "Hell, even Bill admits that Windows is at the end of its rope. You were there! That's the main reason he helped us save Apple. He admitted that we're the only ones who can take the PC to its logical conclusion."

"Steve, you believe that? He tells you one thing, but bastardizes all of our good ideas? I mean, what is this Luna junk?"

"But that's the way Bill plays. He knows that all his work nods to the Mac, but that's the beauty of it all, because Bill doesn't know my master plan."

"What master plan?"

"Sit down, Avie."

Tevanian relents and plops back down into his chair. Jobs pauses a moment, then pulls a chair in alongside Tevanian. For the next few minutes, in the broadest rhetorical brush strokes, he paints a portrait of the next 10 years of his Macintosh dream for his software guru. As he talks, Tevanian nods, smiles and adds a comment here or there. Ultimately, he breaks into a broad grin and shakes his head in wonderment.

"And you really think you can pull it off?"

"Avie, we can pull this off. And if we can pull this off, Tzu Sun himself will be calling our plan "The Art of War," while his will be referred to as an "an okay strategem."

With a sense of déjà vu, he stands and puts his hands on the arms of Tevanian's chair, leaning in front of him face to face.

"Avie, do you want to work the rest of your life on the Mach kernel, a computing footnote -- a fine and watershed footnote, though it is -- or do you want to change the world? The. Mac. Is. Going. To. Change. The. World… again."

As he utters those words, Jobs feels suddenly as if he's said these words before. As he thinks back two decades, he realizes that he has…

Of course, this conversation didn't even occur in the inner sanctum of Apple's power seat, but the plan has probably been articulated, nevertheless.

Apple Computer currently enjoys between three and five percent of the computing market share, depending on whose numbers you are listening. This is a respectable number, translating into millions and millions of users worldwide. But this isn't enough. In order for Apple to remain viable now and in the future, the company has to experience greater year over year growth, much greater than has been the case heretofore.

There are only two places from which that growth can come: attracting new computer users who've never owned a computer before or attracting "defectors" from competing platforms, namely Microsoft Windows users.

The latter group is the logical choice.

Between 90 and 95 percent of computer users worldwide use some flavor of Microsoft's Windows operating system. Ignoring how and why Microsoft has garnered a user base comprising nearly every computer user alive, the fact remains that a vocal portion of this user base is not satisfied with Microsoft's products, if the anecdotal evidence means and says anything.

This is the audience that Apple needs to target. Capitalism demands it, by definition. Apple doesn't really need much a plan. The company needs patience more than anything…

"Steve, you can't really mean it? Apple's going to compete directly with Microsoft? No bull? Ha!"

"Avie, can it be so hard to imagine?"

"Well, yeah. Look at us, man. We exist mainly because Microsoft doesn't see us as a threat any longer. And as soon as they buy their way out of this anti-trust joke, they will turn their 'tender mercies' back to us, and we will go the way of Netscape and Palm."

"Oh, ye of little faith! The plan's success is guaranteed, because it is based upon one the oldest business tactics available to small companies competing with 800-pound gorillas: monopolistic hubris."

"You've better have a plan with more substance than that."

"I do. I just told you my plan: we will continue to release products under Microsoft's radar. You just wait until we unveil iFax, iBrowser and AppleWorks Office -- not to mention iShop, iPhone and iTV. You should know by now that we have to keep the truly killer apps under wraps until the next phase occurs. First, we have to wait for Microsoft to hang itself. Microsoft is testing the tolerance of the buying public. You said yourself that .NET will be the final straw. People will buy it for a while, but will revolt when it reaches its final form: no one suffer long a insatiable Microsoft sitting astride every e-commerce activity under the sun."

"Mmmm-hmmm. But what do we do in the meanwhile, Steve?"

"We do what we're currently doing. We get our house in order. We keep evolving our desktops and laptops, making sure that we stay ahead of Wintel's beige behemoth."

"That's not hard."

"Ain't that the truth, brother. But that's no excuse not to make the PC what it should be. And we need to keep pushing our R & D to take the GUI to the next level; that's why we need you, Avie. Hell, we knew that Microsoft would ape OS X as much as legally possible, even with our détente. Especially with our détente. Which is why we saved the really killer features for future upgrades to OS X. By the way, you should see the latest prototypes of the WebPad. If we ever decide to ship it, we will shake the world the way Sculley's Newton should have."

The revolution will be televised

Armageddon done been in effect! Go get a late pass.

Public Enemy

The end result and ultimate goal of any company is a monopoly, or so the saying goes. This applies to Apple Computer.

There is no way that anyone can say that Apple execs are sitting there, striving hard to be Number Two. There is no way that Steve Jobs is satisfied with Apple setting its goals on achieving a 10 percent market share.

Apple has an ulterior motive to stick it to Microsoft. There just isn't much satisfaction in merely having a cool OS and good-looking hardware.

This ulterior motive has been hinted at on several occasions. For example, in 1998, Fortune magazine's cover story on Apple's resurgence mentioned a comment that Tevanian made about OS X's superiority to Windows (I am not making this part up):

Tevanian suggests it will completely outdo Windows. "The rate of innovation in the Wintel market is very stagnant, " he says. "It's not that difficult to do things that are vastly better than what you see today. What Apple is doing is building better computers."

Which prompted the following:

Responds [Ben] Waldman of Microsoft, with a hint of dismay: "Steve said last August [remember when Bill Gates loomed 1984-like at that Macworld?] that the era of competition between Apple and Microsoft is over."

Shyeah, right. They don't even see it coming. Can Microsoft really be that dumb?

When a bully (or a murderer) has you on the ground with a shotgun at your head, you will agree with him more readily. You will let him have your wallet (money owed Apple from look-and-feel lawsuits). Hell, you may even promise to give him your lunch everyday (fill in the blank with your own conspiracy theory). But as soon as you get a chance, you may begin plotting your revenge. Or, you may plot the ultimate revenge: living well. I don't think Apple can and will plan "revenge" on Microsoft, but I do believe that Apple execs predict that Microsoft will mess up in the public eye one day -- big time -- and Apple will be given opportunity to step in and up. No one else is and will be positioned to challenge Microsoft's throne.

The Linux community is too disjointed by comparison. And OS X, compared to Linux, will be a powerhouse in the three-to-five years it will take for Microsoft's house of cards to unravel.

Apple should be working feverishly the next few years to put into place and infrastructure for making major inroads in terms of market share, mind share and consumer awareness: beef up its server solutions (server hardware present and future, OS X Server, AirPort), its hardware (desktops, laptops and future offerings) and its software offerings, evolving and tweaking them to the point that stability and user experience are second to none.

Meanwhile, Microsoft will play the poster child of insolent corporate pride, running roughshod over competitors and consumers. If the present proves anything, Microsoft's arrogance coupled with its penchant to avoid improving products beyond "just good enough" will push the buying public enough so that the average users will seriously seek and switch to alternatives, chief of which will be a come-of-age Apple Center Every company has its sights on its leading competitor, in hopes of overtaking and even supplanting the competition. Apple should be no different.

This is a bigger task than I make it out to be. Microsoft has a far bigger product portfolio than Apple can ever dream. The key is to compete with Microsoft and yet not compete with Microsoft. Can Apple create software that can successfully challenge Microsoft's stable of products, or should that battlefield be avoided, turning the fight to merely being a struggle for supremacy between OS X and whatever Microsoft will be calling its OS at the time?

And let's not forget that even before Apple gets to the point of having to answer that question, fate may have other things in store for Microsoft. The shifting winds of the legal landscape could very well blow Microsoft apart (don't scoff; the EU appears to be sticking to principle far better than George W. Bush's Washington has). Remember that IBM used to the center of the computing universe, too. IBM's still big, but IBM doesn't shape things as it once did.

If Apple ever does get its act together vis-à-vis hardware and software offerings, and Microsoft does continue on its headstrong path to self-immolation, we may very well see Apple or some other company trying its hand at being the world's computing leader.

Hey, I can dream. I'm sure Steve and Avie do.

Rodney O. Lain is an incurable Pollyanna, on his good days. On his bad days, he fears that Apple will find a way to "eff up all of this good stuff." When he isn't dreaming of a Mac OS-dominated world, he is a regular contributor to The Mac Observer with his "iBrotha" column, as well as the occasional editorial. He lives in Minnesota, the home of Best Buy and other freaks of nature.

Recent TMO Headlines - Updated September 26th

Mon, 8:08 PM
iMovie for Mac gets HEVC Support
Mon, 5:55 PM
An Extraordinary Review of the Apple TV 4K
Mon, 5:41 PM
Here are Some Apps that Are (or Maybe Aren't) macOS High Sierra Compatible
Mon, 5:12 PM
TMO Background Mode Interview with Red-Sweater Software Founder Daniel Jalkut
Mon, 4:44 PM
Mac Pro Users: macOS High Sierra has a Firmware Update for You
Mon, 3:15 PM
Get Free Bitcoins from 50 Faucets That Pay
Mon, 3:07 PM
Here's a Direct Link to Download macOS High Sierra
Mon, 2:52 PM
macOS High Sierra Performs a Weekly EFI Security Check
Mon, 2:34 PM
Siri Web Search Will Switch to Google From Bing
Mon, 2:32 PM
Time Machine and APFS: What You Need to Know
Mon, 2:21 PM
Preparation Guide For macOS High Sierra Installation
Mon, 1:42 PM
Get Ready for macOS High Sierra - TMO Daily Observations 2017-09-25
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!