Microsoft Dealt Legal Blow Against Windows Trademark

Microsoft has been pursing a suit against Lindows, seeking to stop that company from using the name Lindows, as well as seeking to stop the company from releasing its signature product. Lindows is designed to allow Linux users to run Windows software on Linux. Microsoft had been seeking a preliminary injunction against Lindows that would immediately stop them from doing these things, which a judge denied in March of this year. In the ruling handed down in that decision, the judge said that questions of whether or not Windows could be a trademark term at all had been raised.

Microsoft appealed that decision, telling the judge he had erred. The judge has handed down a new ruling in that appeal, again denying Microsoftis requests. From a press release (not a news story) issued by

Judge Coughenour wrote in a seven page ruling that after "examining the evidence with a sharper focus" news articles, advertisements, competitors and dictionary definitions demonstrated that the "consuming public used the terms iwindows,i iwindowi and iwindowingi to refer to a type of graphical user interface." The Western Washington District Judge also wrote that through "its own use of the evidence" Microsoft essentially admits that "windows" is a generic term. The Court bolstered that finding by citing Microsoftis own computer dictionary definition, as well as quotes from then Vice President of Marketing, Steve Ballmer, in discussing the introduction of Windows 1.0. To read the document in its entirety, visit

Microsoft had contended that the Court had a "fundamental misapprehension" and had "reached an incorrect result" in an earlier ruling in which the Court stated that Microsoft had raised "serious questions" about the validity of its windows trademark and refused to halt from using both and LindowsOS for its operating system name.

In the latest ruling, the Court found that it "did not err in either its legal or factual analysis when it denied Microsoftis motion for a preliminary injunction" against

"Microsoft pulled the pin on this grenade and the Judge made them swallow it," said, Inc., Chief Executive Officer Michael Robertson. "Our goal is to bring choice back to computers in spite of Microsoftis bullying tactics. If we have to go to trial where the word "windows" will be declared generic, weire prepared to do so."

You can read the full press release at the site. C|Net is reporting that Microsoft intends to take the case to trial.