Apple Investigating Reported iPhone-Related Electrocution in China

| Analysis

Apple in ChinaApple said it is investigating an incident where a woman in China was reportedly electrocuted when using her iPhone. The device was supposedly charging at the time, though details are scarce.

At the heart of the report is a tweet, or rather a post to Weibo, a Twitter analogue that is very popular in China. The sister of Ma Ailun, a 23-year old flight attendant from the Xinjiang region, Weiboed that the woman collapsed and died after using her charging iPhone 5.

According to Reuters, that went viral on Weibo and was picked up by the state-owned Xinhua news agency in China. Apple issued a statement offering the company's corporate condolences and promising to investigate the issue and cooperate with authorities.

"We are deeply saddened to learn of this tragic incident and offer our condolences to the Ma family," Apple told Reuters in an email. "We will fully investigate and cooperate with authorities in this matter."

What's lacking is any sort of confirmation that Ms. Ma died, that she died while using her iPhone 5, or whether the iPhone had anything to do with her death. In that this is the first report of such a death with hundreds of millions of iPhones in the wild, this smacks of instant-urban legend, conclusion without cause, or better yet, a whisper campaign.

Apple has been the target of an orchestrated campaign of harassment from the Chinese government for months. That government has employed state media, state-owned companies, government regulators, and Chinese celebrities to criticize and attack Apple.

Which is not to downplay the tragedy of Ms. Ma's death or the loss to her family and friends. It's just that there have been no cases of iPhone-related electrocution to date and it doesn't seem likely now.

If the iPhone was defective in some way, Apple will have a problem on its hand, both in terms of public relations and the problem of addressing the malfunction. If the iPhone wasn't involved, it will still have a public relations nightmare to manage as the story lives on in popular culture.




I read that she was reportedly shocked when trying to answer a call on the iPhone. While I can imagine that there is a slight possibility of a charger malfunction sending full wall current into the phone, were that the case I truly doubt the phone would have been working at all, let alone able to ring. And that’s assuming the sync cable didn’t immediately fry as well, were such a wall current surge to take place.

Hopefully this just turns out to be urban legend, and no one will have been hurt in any way.

Lee Dronick

Have there been other incidents with cell phones, calculators and such? As with mrmwebmax I would hardly think it possible, but maybe. We need more info.


I haven’t been to China. I did spend two months in Russia in a rented flat. Sparks flew a couple of times when something was plugged in. One item had its’ circuitry fried. What really scared me is how many people stacked lots of things onto one outlet. Now, if you add some moisture to that then things would be very dangerous.

I cannot see how the charge wire on any phone could cause electrocution. Maybe it could stop someone’s heart if there were an underlying problem.

Lee Dronick

Perhaps if she grabbed the transformer. I wonder if was an Apple charger or 3rd party.

Lee Dronick

The idiots on one of our loval TV news shows is reporting this as fact. I have more respect for politicians than I do for most newscasters and reporters.

Lee Dronick

Would clearing out the cookie and or data base stop this from happening?

Log in to comment (TMO, Twitter or Facebook) or Register for a TMO account