Judge: No Injunction for Samsung Galaxy SIII

| News

Apple’s efforts to block the launch of Samsung’s Galaxy SIII in the United States fell apart this week when Judge Lucy Koh said there wasn’t enough time to add a hearing for the smartphone to her court calendar. The Galaxy SIII is set to go on sale on Thursday, June 21, and it looks like there isn’t anything Apple can do to stop Samsung from selling its new smartphone — at least for now.

Samsung gets to sell its Galaxy SIII smartphone in the U.S.Samsung gets to sell its Galaxy SIII smartphone in the U.S.

Judge Koh’s decision, according to Reuters, doesn’t imply that Apple can’t get an injunction; instead, it’s simply a matter of timing. With only a week to review all of the information in the case, she doesn’t have enough time to work through all of the details and issue a ruling.

The decision to leave an injunction ruling off the table for now is good news for Samsung since the company doesn’t have to worry about potential launch delays. For Apple, however, it means that yet another Samsung smartphone that it claims steps on iPhone-related patents will hit the market.

According to Apple, Samsung’s strategy is to flood the market with smartphones faster than the legal system can deal with the related patent infringement claims. Samsung’s view is that Apple is trying to litigate phones off the market instead of competing.

Apple and Samsung have been locked in a legal battle over patent infringement claims for several months. Both companies have alleged that the other’s mobile devices use patented technologies without proper licensing, and have filed lawsuits against each other in the U.S. and other countries.

With the companies still fighting in court over their patent infringement claims, there’s still a chance Apple will get an injunction blocking the sale of the Galaxy SIII, but not before it hits store shelves.

Sign Up for the Newsletter

Join the TMO Express Daily Newsletter to get the latest Mac headlines in your e-mail every weekday.

Comments

Bosco (Brad Hutchings)

Of course there is something Apple can do! They can make a phone that GS3 purchasers would want to buy instead. Some features that are important: large screen, OS that had notifications right 2+ years ago, choice of app stores, apps available even if they break silly UI rules, compete against the OS vendor, or whatever. 4G/LTE wouldn’t hurt.

peter

samsung is clearly copied Apple’s smart phones, tablet computers, there’s no doubt about it.  How could California Northern Court assigned a Korean judge to oversee this case and expecting a fair sentence to Apple?

Mark

Wow, really, you are speaking about a Korean judge, when you yourself haven?t even mastered proper grammar.

(samsung is clearly copied) (this case and expecting a fair sentence)

Emil J Wisekal

Of course there is something Apple can do! They can make a phone that GS3 purchasers would want to buy instead. Some features that are important: large screen, OS that had notifications right 2+ years ago, choice of app stores, apps available even if they break silly UI rules, compete against the OS vendor, or whatever. 4G/LTE wouldn?t hurt.

daemon

I’m starting to think we’re not going to see a new iPhone this year. It’s unlike Apple to offer iOS support to a device four generations behind…

No, I’m fairly certain Apple has ran out of ideas other than to offer the feature bloat they so wisely avoided the last five years…

Log-in to comment