Nokia Takes ITC Complaint to New Lawsuit Against Apple

| News

Apple vs. NokiaNokia has launched a new patent lawsuit against Apple, a suit that echoes complaints the company has already made to the International Trade Commission (ITC) that basically everything Apple makes violates one or more of Nokia's patents. According to ArsTechnica, the suit was filed the same day the company lodged its complaint with the ITC.

The new suit is in addition to a an iPhone-related patent infringement lawsuit Nokia filed against Apple in October, where Nokia alleges that Apple violates 10 of its wireless technology-related patents in manufacturing the iPhone. Apple fired back with a countersuit in December with its own patent infringement claims.

Nokia responded to Apple's response with a complaint to the ITC that other Apple products violate Nokia patents, including iPods, MacBooks, and iMacs. The new lawsuit includes the same complaints, but in the legal arena.

The lawsuits are all part of the battle between the two companies on who gets to use which patented technology, and how much they will have to pay to do it. Nokia was once the dominant smartphone maker, and is still the largest handset maker on the planet.

In recent years, however, the company's Symbian OS has been overshadowed by BlackBerry and iPhone OS, as well as Google's Android, and the patent suits are seen as a strategy of getting access to several of Apple patents that would make it easier for Nokia to develop a smartphone that can compete with the iPhone.

Failing that, however, a successful claim against Apple in the courts or in the international trade agreement realm (as represented by the ITC) would at least net Nokia substantial money, possibly billions of dollars (US). Apple, a company that almost never comments about ongoing litigation, served notice that it takes this fight seriously by announcing the above-mentioned countersuit via press release.


Laurie Fleming

Classic quote from The Onion, eleven years ago:

“If this patent holds up in federal court, Apple will have no choice but to convert to analog,” said Apple interim CEO Steve Jobs, “and I have serious doubts whether this company would be able to remain competitive selling pedal-operated computers running software off vinyl LPs.”

Microsoft patents ones and zeroes

The way I see it, capitalism, to misquote Churchill, is the worst form of economics, except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time. This is one area where it does not show itself up in the best light. All these companies, Apple included, preach competition but really what they want is their own little monopoly once they’ve gained a sufficient foothold.

Stop throwing your toys out of your cot and grow up, the lot of you.

Log in to comment (TMO, Twitter or Facebook) or Register for a TMO account