US Court Says Bitcoin is Money, Can be Regulated

| News

A U.S. Federal Court has ruled that Bitcoins can be considered an actual currency, and as such falls under government regulation. The ruling was part of a case where a man was charged with using Bitcoins in a ponzi scheme that defrauded investors out of over US$1 million.

U.S. Court says Bitcoin can be regulated just like other currencies and securitiesU.S. Court says Bitcoin can be regulated just like other currencies and securities

In his ruling, Judge Amos Mazzant said that Bitcoin is a security because people exchange it for real goods and services. He stated,

It is clear that Bitcoin can be used as money. It can be used to purchase goods or services, and as Shavers stated, used to pay for individual living expenses. The only limitation of Bitcoin is that it is limited to those places that accept it as currency. However, it can also be exchanged for conventional currencies, such as the U.S. dollar, Euro, Yen, and Yuan. Therefore, Bitcoin is a currency or form of money, and investors wishing to invest in BTCST provided an investment of money.

Bitcoin is a virtual currency that doesn't have any type of physical asset or government to back it up. The value of an individual Bitcoin can rise and fall, just like other financial investments, and a Bitcoin can be traded for traditional forms of money.

The ruling came in a case where Trendon Shavers was accused of fraud for when he raised over 700,000 Bitcoins from investors in his Bitcoin Savings and Trust company in 2011 and 2012. While he made plenty of money off the scheme, most of his investors did not.

Mr. Shavers had hoped to convince the court it, and the Securities and Exchange Commission, didn't have jurisdiction over his Bitcoin venture because the currency was virtual and didn't qualify as actual money. With Judge Mazzant's ruling it's clear Mr. Shavers didn't succeed in swaying the court.

The ruling has implications that go beyond Mr. Shaver's case because it establishes government jurisdiction over Bitcoin as a currency, and that means it can be regulated just like any other security.

One of the draws Bitcoin has is that it is grew outside of government control and regulation, and is a system for anonymous transactions. Bitcoin units aren't directly tied to a person's name or government system, like a Social Security Number, making them extremely difficult to track. They also included the allure of being, from a legal stand point, not real money and safe from government control.

It's clear governments see Bitcoin as a currency they need to control, and Judge Mazzant's concise ruling is a great framework for establishing that regulation. Mr. Shavers may appeal the ruling, but he may have a hard time getting that overturned because the Judge's arguments for government regulation were clear and compelling.

[Thanks to Ars Technica for the heads up]

The Mac Observer Spin The Mac Observer Spin is how we show you what our authors think about a news story at quick glance. Read More →

Letting the Bitcoin economy happen outside of government control doesn't sit well with lawmakers, and Judge Mazzant's ruling is a pretty clear argument for why it should be treated like any other currency. Like it or not, governments will keep working to bring Bitcoin under their control.

Popular TMO Stories



Bitcoin units aren’t directly tied to a person’s name or government system, like a Social Security Number, making them extremely difficult to track.

Tracking bitcoins is actually very easy, as the transaction log for every bitcoin is publically open. What’s difficult is that the identifying account for each transaction is a cryptographic public key. And each bitcoin has it’s own transaction log.

So, it’s not that it’s hard to track bitcoins, it’s that there’s just so much data involved in tracking them.


As long as the corresponding taxes occur in the virtual world for this virtual currency…

Try to apply real dollar taxes to virtual money and prepare for the backlash.

Lee Dronick

Backlash is one thing, Treasury Agents are another.


Litecoins might be the other way to get around the bitcoin scrutiny, much easier to buy and trade at LiteTree litecoin exchange.

Glenn Diecedue

Bitcoins? Whether you want it or not by you reading this post means you could be one of the first to make a lot of money on the people that come after you!  The Bitcoin Robot is a unique concept that has very little to do with trading in the conventional way!  It is based entirely on the “Human Greed” factor. Making You earn while 90% of the people that run towards bitcoin pay too much to own bitcoins while filling your pockets in the process! Go get the full scoop here:

Terrone Davis

My Feathercoin giveaway has began! I am a large holder in Feathercoins and want to boost it’s popularity. To do this I am offering the equivalent of 10$ in feathercoins for every person that gets the feathercoinQT wallet and sends me their newly made address.

I will be doing this up to the one hundredth address I recieve and depending on the results I get on the ftc market I will either continue or discontinue these giveaways. Please do not attempt to send me multiple addresses, I have my ways of finding out. After downloading the wallet send me a pm on here with your ftc address. Hope you realise the investment opportunity that is feathercoin!

You can get the wallet from

Log in to comment (TMO, Twitter or Facebook) or Register for a TMO account