A federal jury in San Diego has hit Apple with a massive $5.7 billion penalty for patent infringement. The ruling favors Taction Technology, a firm that initially filed the lawsuit back in 2021. According to the court, the internal hardware powering the physical feedback in Apple products violates two specific patents owned by Taction. This stands as the largest patent verdict in the country to date.
The jury focuses on two specific vibration patents
The lawsuit centers around the Taptic Engine. This is the hardware component Apple uses to create tapping sensations for notifications and screen interactions. Taction Technology argued that this hardware infringed on its intellectual property.
Specifically, the court looked at US Patent No. 10,659,885 and No. 10,820,117. The jury agreed that the iPhone maker used this patented technology unlawfully.
Don’t miss the best of The Mac Observer
Set us as a preferred source and our Apple reporting ranks higher in your Google Search results and Discover feed — one tap, no account changes.
However, the jury did not find that the infringement was willful. The decision simply confirms that the hardware overlaps with the inventions Taction previously patented. For a company that relies heavily on custom components, a penalty of this size is a major legal blow.
Apple plans an appeal as the legal fight continues
The hardware manufacturer disputes the outcome of the trial. It argues that its Taptic Engine is fundamentally different from the inventions patented by Taction Technology.
Because of this disagreement, the recent verdict does not end the dispute. The company confirmed it will appeal the decision. Moving forward, a higher court will need to review the technical details to decide if the initial penalty holds up.
If the ruling stands, it could force device makers to be much more careful about how they build vibration features. The final outcome will likely set a new standard for how patent claims are handled across Apple products and the wider tech industry.
Discussion