The Mac Observer

Skip navigational links

You're viewing an article in TMO's historic archive vault. Here, we've preserved the comments and how the site looked along with the article. Use this link to view the article on our current site:
Apple Faces iPod, iTunes Patent Suits

Apple Faces iPod, iTunes Patent Suits

by , 7:35 AM EST, March 7th, 2005

Two separate companies have filed patent lawsuits against Apple Computer alledging the company has violated their patents related to the iPod digital music device and the iTunes Music Store (iTMS).

Chicago-based Advanced Audio Devices LLC has sued Apple claiming the iPod violates one of its patents for a "music jukebox."

The company's patent, filed with the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office in August of 2000 and granted in July of 2003, describes a music "jukebox" for storing a "music library".

"The music jukebox includes a housing, audio input structure on the housing for receiving audio signals, audio output structure on the housing for outputting audio signals, and a data storage structure in the housing for storing audio signals," the filing said.

The Chicago Tribune reported Friday the company tried to settle with Apple in December over its claim. Apple "ignored its attempt to seek a business resolution," the complaint states.

Advanced Audio Devices LLC was founded in 1997 by Peter J. Keller.

In addition, Hong Kong-based Pat-rights has also filed suit against Apple claiming its digital rights management technology violates its patent that was granted in December of 2003.

Pat-rights patent describes a method of "protecting publicly distributed software from unauthorized use" using a sub-program for encryption, a sub-program "for authorizing (the) use of a software product," and a sub-program for authenticating a users computer.

The patent holding company claims Apple has not patented its Fairplay technology and that for that reason it must be using its patent. "This is certainly a patentable technology," Pat-right president Peter Chung said in a prepared statement released in late February. "If iTunes does not patent it, there must be a very good reason for them not to do so- someone else has patented this."

The company is demanding 12% of gross sales from Apple's iTMS and is giving Apple 21 days to accept what Pat-rights is calling "a reasonable license fee." At that point on or around March 21st, Pat-rights intends on filing suit for copyright infringement against Apple.

If it decides to file suit against Apple, the company plans on seeking damages up to three times its original value. The company has yet to determine a resonable value.

Recent Headlines - Updated April 21st

Sat, 9:02 PM
3 Free iOS Apps To Unleash the Music In You
10:30 AM
Yet Another 25 Tips for Mastering iPhone Photography
Fri, 7:25 PM
Look Out Apple Haters, Android’s Monopoly on Large Screens Will End
5:20 PM
Why Apple Didn’t Try to Copy Google Glass
4:30 PM
Menu Bars Of The Stars
4:12 PM
How to Streamline System Preferences on Your Mac
2:56 PM
Microsoft Pilot Program Allows Developers to Respond to App Reviews
1:15 PM
Tavik’s Zippered Folio Case for iPad Air is Built for Travel
1:13 PM
Apple Maps Misses Your Coffee Shop, but Finds Loch Ness Monster
12:55 PM
Online Privacy: Track Which Apps Access Your Personal Information
10:56 AM
Judge Denies Rockstar Consortium’s Bid to Move Google Patent Fight to Troll Town
9:25 AM
Dropbox gets Deeper into Photo Management with Loom Purchase
  • __________
  • Buy Stuff, Support TMO!
  • Podcast: Mac Geek Gab
  • Podcast: Apple Weekly Report
  • TMO on Twitter!