AirPods 5 vs AirPods 2: Upgrading From the Classic Lightning AirPods

Apple AirPods 5 hero
Image: Apple

AirPods 5 costs $129, or $149 with the Wireless Charging Case, and against the second-generation AirPods from 2019 it adds Active Noise Cancellation, an IP57 water and dust rating, the H2 chip and a USB-C case. The 2019 model launched at $159 with the Charging Case and $199 with the Wireless Charging Case, was cut to $129 in October 2021, and carries no water rating on Apple’s spec page at all.

Apple AirPods 5 Wireless Charging Case
The $149 case charges over USB-C, Qi and Apple Watch chargers, and it is the only one with a speaker. Image: Apple

That means the entry price is the same one Apple settled on for the old model five years ago, and almost everything else about the product has changed. Every figure below comes from Apple’s tech specs pages and Apple’s press releases.

Key facts: AirPods 5 against the 2019 AirPods

SpecAirPods 5AirPods (2nd generation, 2019)
Price$129, or $149 with the Wireless Charging Case$159 or $199 at launch, cut to $129 in October 2021
ChipH2H1
Active Noise CancellationYes, in an open-ear designNo
Listening per chargeUp to 6 hours with noise control off, 4 hours with ANC onUp to 5 hours
Total with the caseUp to 20 hours, or 22 hours on the $149 modelMore than 24 hours
Case chargingUSB-C, plus Qi and Apple Watch chargers on the $149 caseLightning, plus Qi on the Wireless Charging Case
Water and dustIP57 for buds and caseNo rating listed
Weight4.3 g per bud, 32.3 g or 34.7 g case4 g per bud, 38.2 g case

Apple stopped selling the second-generation AirPods some time ago, so those prices are historical. The current standard model is AirPods 5 and the current Pro is AirPods Pro 3 at $249.

Don’t miss the best of The Mac Observer

Set us as a preferred source and our Apple reporting ranks higher in your Google Search results and Discover feed — one tap, no account changes.

Or get it by email
Apple AirPods 5 lifestyle
AirPods 5 keeps the open-ear fit and adds an IP57 dust, sweat and water rating. Image: Apple

The noise cancellation the 2019 model never had

Nothing on the old spec sheet touches noise control. Apple’s press release calls AirPods 5 the first open-ear AirPods with Active Noise Cancellation at this level, rated at up to 50 percent more noise removed than AirPods 4 with ANC, and its marketing page states the same figure as up to 1.5 times the noise cancellation of the previous generation.

Apple credits a new multiport acoustic architecture inspired by AirPods Pro 3 plus improved computational audio, and the full noise-control list for AirPods 5 runs to Active Noise Cancellation, Transparency, Adaptive Audio, Conversation Awareness and Voice Isolation. The sound hardware is new too: a custom high-excursion driver, a high dynamic range amplifier, a vent system for pressure equalization and next-generation Adaptive EQ. Our AirPods 5 announcement coverage sets out what Apple claimed on stage.

Apple iPhone 18 Pro Photos app Apple Reference Image
Siri AI, Live Translation and Custom EQ for AirPods 5 arrive with iOS 27 on September 14. Image: Apple

Battery and charging: USB-C replaces Lightning

Battery and chargingAirPods 5 ($129 / $149)AirPods (2nd generation)
Listening per charge6 h / 7 h with noise control off5 h
Listening with ANC on4 h / 5 hNot applicable
Total with the case20 h / 22 hMore than 24 hours
Quick charge5 minutes for around 1 hour of listening15 minutes for up to 3 hours of listening
CableUSB-CLightning
Wireless charging$149 case only, Qi and Apple Watch chargersWireless Charging Case only, Qi

Be honest about the trade. Per charge the new model is an hour ahead with noise control off, but the old case held more than 24 hours of listening against 20 or 22 hours now, so the total shrinks. The cable changes as well, which matters if every charger in your house is still Lightning.

One more practical difference: only the $149 AirPods 5 case has a speaker, so it is the only one that can play a sound through Find My. Both AirPods 5 models get separation alerts.

The software gap is the real story

  • Hands-free Siri AI, which Apple describes as access to a more powerful and personalized assistant.
  • Live Translation, which needs an Apple Intelligence iPhone on the latest OS.
  • Siri Interactions: nod to accept a call or message, shake your head to decline.
  • Voice Isolation and studio-quality audio recording.
  • Personalized Spatial Audio with dynamic head tracking, and Listen together audio sharing between two sets of AirPods.
  • Custom EQ, which Apple lists among the AirPods changes on its iOS 27 page.

All of that rides on the H2 chip and on iOS 27, which arrives on Monday, September 14 as a free update. The H1 generation gets none of it, and Apple has not suggested otherwise. Apple also lists 40 percent recycled material by weight for AirPods 5, a figure it did not publish for the 2019 model.

What Apple has not said

  • Any comparison between AirPods 5 and the second-generation AirPods. Apple’s stated reference point is AirPods 4 with ANC.
  • Talk time for either model. Both spec pages list listening hours only.
  • A dust or water rating for the 2019 AirPods, which is why the table says none is listed.
  • A trade-in credit for old AirPods. Apple’s trade-in page shows no per-model dollar figure.
  • The colors AirPods 5 comes in. The tech specs page does not name them.

If your 2019 AirPods still work, the upgrade is about noise cancellation, water resistance and the new Siri features rather than raw battery life. AirPods 5 is on pre-order now at $129 or $149 and lands in stores on Friday, September 18 in the US and more than 65 countries, and our event live blog has the announcement as it happened.